tilmeedh
06-12-2005, 01:32 AM
http://i32.photobucket.com/albums/d26/tahasyed/salam.gif
No doubt, dhikr has a great place in Islam, be it something specifically prescribed by the Prophet (s) or not. No Muslim denies that.
Now here is my concern:
When the Prophet (s) prescribed certain adhkar, he did so with the Will of Allah, and the reward promised by him is the reward promised by Allah.
But something I noticed among the shias and sufis is that there are certain non-Prophetic ritualistic adhkar that are prescribed, at times attached with a 'gaurantee'. e.g. do abc so many times, and xyz so many times and such-and-such will happen.
Now I want to know what place this has in shari'ah. Surely, the act in itself is a praiseworthy act of dhikr. But when it is ritualized with a certain reward visualized in one's mind, is this not a form of bid'a in worship?
Shias call them a'maal (prescribed by an imam), and I think the sufi couterpart is a wird (prescribed by a shaykh)?
Any clarification will be greatly appreciated.
ws
No doubt, dhikr has a great place in Islam, be it something specifically prescribed by the Prophet (s) or not. No Muslim denies that.
Now here is my concern:
When the Prophet (s) prescribed certain adhkar, he did so with the Will of Allah, and the reward promised by him is the reward promised by Allah.
But something I noticed among the shias and sufis is that there are certain non-Prophetic ritualistic adhkar that are prescribed, at times attached with a 'gaurantee'. e.g. do abc so many times, and xyz so many times and such-and-such will happen.
Now I want to know what place this has in shari'ah. Surely, the act in itself is a praiseworthy act of dhikr. But when it is ritualized with a certain reward visualized in one's mind, is this not a form of bid'a in worship?
Shias call them a'maal (prescribed by an imam), and I think the sufi couterpart is a wird (prescribed by a shaykh)?
Any clarification will be greatly appreciated.
ws