PDA

View Full Version : HELP: a question on Al Wara Wal Bara amongst muslims



Misty_Water
21-01-2006, 06:33 PM
Asalaam Alaikum

I had a question about al wara wal bara (loving and hating for the sake of Allah). I understand we should disassociate ourselves with muslims who take their deen very lightly but yet at the same time we need to make sure we don't completely cut them off, as it is our duty to do dawah and bring them to the straight path of islam.

However,i wanted to know was whether it is permissible to disassociate yourself from practising muslims, just because you feel they are effecting your imaan in a negative way, even though this is not what they intended. Usually when muslim brothers and sisters get to know each other they initially speak about islam but as time passes, they start speaking idle talk. If a person feels this is distracting them from their imaan and other duties such as towards their parents and studies, then is it permissible to cut off ties with these people, despite them being very good and pious muslims?

JazaakAllahu Khayraan

Wasalaam

Omar HH
21-01-2006, 06:52 PM
We do not hate the Muslim we hate his sin.

Shaykh `Ali al-`Iraqi al-Sharif al-Husayni answered this:

Bismillahi rahmani rahim


From the point of view of fiqh:
It is recommended to befriend such people if we think we will influence them.
It is haram to befriend such people if we think they will influence us.
It is permitted or makruh such people if we think we won’t influence them nor they will influence us.
From the point of view of tasawwuf:
We should only befriend those who will rise our state not those who will make it drop.
Sometimes we befriend people with a lower state than us in order to feel superior because if we befriend those with a higher state we will feel inferior. You should know which is your case.

And Allah knows best.

Sidi Ali Laraki
__________________