Harry Nutter

[3ainab]

I have a sister who reads the "harry potter" book like one should read the Quraan! Honestly looking at her makes me think of Hazrat Uthmaan and his devotion to the holy Quraan! Correct me if im wrong but im sure your not allowed to read such books that gets you all hypnotized especially when its all about magic and whatever it is (im not sure cos i hate that book).
So what d'you all fink?( Hope there arent any Potter fans out there :rolleyes:)

[UmmeGibrel]

I have a sister who used to be potter crazy... after the final book, she is not much bothered.

May Allah have mercy on all of us. Ameen.

[UmmeGibrel]

Some discussions here on Harry Nutter we had before:

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=22605&highlight=harry+potter

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=24820&highlight=harry+potter

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=24459&highlight=harry+potter

[loveProphet]

I wonder if the Muslims had this much controversy with the Arabian nights?

[UmmeGibrel]

It ain't that much famous i guess... harry potter has gained quite a lot of publicity... Poeple all over the globe know about this book in particular.

[3ainab]

[QUOTE=onlyfaith;260387]I have a sister who used to be potter crazy... after the final book, she is not much bothered.

Good for you sis,mine finished reading the last one and then started reading the first one again! nwayz thanks for the info. And may the Almighty have mercy on all of us, AAMEEN

[abuhajira]

:salam:

Any time I picked up a fiction book or novel.. I said to my self.. You are not a fluent reader, and you will spend hours on this book...and on top of that you will be accountable for the time you spend on this book..this much trouble and then justify it to Allah as well.. why not read something beneficial..

thinking that I put it down and start reading some Islamic book.. :)

:ws:

[!!!Amina!!!]

My cousins are crazy about Harry Potter...My sister too was a great fan but not anymore (Thank the lord).....i dont see wats so gud bout it...its all just plain noncense :mad:

[Kantz]

Salam,

Well said!

I was a fan of Robert Ludlum many years ago...somehow there was a lesson to be learnt...I was reading one of his novel, in a train journey to an airport in one particular country..there sharing the same berth was a group of brothers...whose language I could hardly understand...One of the brothers was pointing at my book and mentioned in a laud and audible voice. I picked that remarks and scribbled it on the front page of the book. As I wanted to understand what he actually commenting on.

He pull his book to read too...it was an arabic book.

That remarks from this dear brother leaves a mark in my life...the remark that he made was...'Oh my God she is reading "TRASH" !!!!'

Upon reaching home I trashed all of Ludlum's collections out into the bin....

No more fictions for me!!!..

[naznin]

I have a sister who reads the "harry potter" book like one should read the Quraan! Honestly looking at her makes me think of Hazrat Uthmaan and his devotion to the holy Quraan! Correct me if im wrong but im sure your not allowed to read such books that gets you all hypnotized especially when its all about magic and whatever it is (im not sure cos i hate that book).
So what d'you all fink?( Hope there arent any Potter fans out there :rolleyes:)

it'll wear off eventually insha'Allah. I used to be a harry potter fan, but realized its a waste of time. Islamic history and stories are way more 'fantastic' ;)

[3ainab]

:salam:

Any time I picked up a fiction book or novel.. I said to my self.. You are not a fluent reader, and you will spend hours on this book...and on top of that you will be accountable for the time you spend on this book..this much trouble and then justify it to Allah as well.. why not read something beneficial..

thinking that I put it down and start reading some Islamic book.. :)

:ws:

Mashallah,may the Almighty help us all to have such high thoughts!aameen

[hugga12]

salam

harry potter is harry nutter

first of all i would state tht people usually imitate



in hary potter rons sister has an ilegal relationship with harry-



do we really want to expose our youth to this?