View Full Version : Books by Allamah Sarfaraz Khan Safdar
Talhah
07-03-2008, 03:08 AM
Assalam-u-'Alaikum
Recently, i came across a marvelous book by Maulana Sarfaraz Ahmad Safdar (A Graduate from Darul-Uloom Deoband and Muhtamim at Jami'ah Nusratul-Uloom Guranwala, Pakistan), by the name Taskeen-us-Sudoor--Tahqeeq Ahwalul-Mauta fil-Barzakhi wal-Qubur (in Urdu), a book explaining conditions after Death, along with the Tawassul issue, in detail, with ample, stong proofs. On the backside of the book, were written names of some other great books by him, Izalatu-Rayb (on the Ilm-e-Ghayb issue), MAqam-e-Imam Abu Hanifah, Tark Qirat Khalful-Imam (not reciting the Surah (Fatihah) behind the Imam), Chahl MAsaa'il Hazraat-e-Barelviyyah (40 issues concerning the Barelvis), TAlaaq-e-Thalathah, etc. So, my question is that are these books and this author reliable-- i havent heard much of him and even heard (from an anti-Deobandi source) that he brought some fabricated and false statements and quotaions in his books-- is it true?
Wassalaam
:salam:
All books of Muhaqqiq Allamah Sarfraz Khan Safdar are reliable and highly recommended for anyone who can read Urdu.
According to Darul Uloom Deoband he is a Muhaqqiq of our time:
Hazrat Maulana Sarfaraaz Khan Safdar has a number of research (tahgeeqi) books and academic achievements; if he is given a title of Muhaqqiul Asr it is not objectionable. There are Muhaqqiqs other than him as well in the world.
http://www.darulifta-deoband.org/viewfatwa.jsp?ID=1917
When asked about Taqwiyat-ul-Iman:
It is an authentic book. For details, please study Ibaraat-e-Akaabir (written by Hazrat Maulana Sarfaraz Safdar).
http://www.darulifta-deoband.org/viewfatwa.jsp?ID=1317
Mufti Taqi Usmani has mentioned in Al-Kalam al-Mufeed that he possess all the books by Allamah Sahib and they have benefited him alot.
Mufti Saeed Ahmad Jalalpuri, Mufti Zar Wali Khan and others refer to him as "Imam Ahl-i-Sunnat." Mufti Zar Wali Khan has also mentioned that Shaykh Sarfraz has authored 160 books, 2nd most amongst the Deobandi scholars, after Hakim al-Ummat Mawlana Thanwi.
Hakim alaUmmah (may Allah have mercy on him) authored around 1385 books, while Mufti Muhammad Shafi (may Allah have mercy on him) authored around 150 books.
And just to mention small biography, Shaykh studied hadith in Deoband under Shaykh al-Islam Hussain Ahmed Madani, and some of his other teachers are Shaykh al-Adab Mawlana Aizaz Ali, Mawlana Muhammed Ibrahim Bilyawi, Mawlana Abdul Qadir, and also studied under Mufti Muhammed Shafi for few months. In Tasawwuf, he was bayat to Shaykh al-Quran Mawlana Hussain Ali [student of Imam Gangohi]. [:rahim: ]
If you have read Taskeen al-Sudur, this it says in there that this book was written at the special request of Muhaddith Allamah Yusuf Binori, Mawlana Mufti Mahmud, and Mufti Muhammed Shafi. Also refer to preface of the book, written by many of all the senior Ulema such as Qari Muhammed Tayyab Qasmi, Muhaddith Habib al-Rahman Azami, Shaykh al-Islam Zaffar Ahmed Usmani, Mawlana Mufti Mahmud, Mufti Sayyid Mahdi Hassan [:rahim:] and many more.
Make dua for the health of Shaykh, as recently he had an eye operation. Shaykh is in his late 90s now. I am sure you have heard of Mawlana Zahid al-Rashidi, that's his son. If you have any more questions, do ask.
Darul Uloom Deoband on Taskin al-Sudur:
از راہ کرم، کیا مسئلہٴ حیاة النبی صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے سلسلے میں وضاحت فرمائیں گے؟
براہ مہربانی اس مسئلہ کے لیے *تسکین الصدور* کا مطالعہ فرمائیں، یہ کتاب پاکستان کے مشہور عالم و محدث مولانا صفدر صاحب کی لکھی ہوئی ہے اور کافی و وافی ہے اور قرآن و حدیث سے مدلل ہے، ہندوستان میں بھی یہ کتاب چھپ گئی ہے، دیوبند کے کسی کتب خانہ سے منگواسکتے ہیں۔
اس مسئلہ کو بے شمار مرتبہ لکھا جاچکا ہے۔ آپ اس مسئلہ کی تحقیق چاہتے ہیں تو تسکین الصدور شیخ الحدیث ابوالزاہد مولانا سرفراز خاں صفدر کی کتاب مطالعہ کریں۔ انھوں نے علمائے دیوبند کے مسلک کوخوب واضح کرکے لکھ دیا ہے۔ اور متعدد شبہات کے جوابات بھی دیئے ہیں۔
http://darulifta-deoband.org/urdu/viewfatwa_u.jsp?ID=562
Ibarat-i-Akabir is also recommended:
آپ اس موضوع پر لکھی ہوئی کتاب مثلاً عباراتِ اکابر مصنفہ مولانا سرفراز خاں صفدر پاکستان کامطالعہ کریں اور اچھی طرح سمجھ لیں اگر کوئی اشکال رہ جائے تو مقامی کسی عالم سے سمجھ لیں یا یہاں لکھ کر بھیجیں۔
http://darulifta-deoband.org/urdu/viewfatwa_u.jsp?ID=2788
یہ نہیں لکھا تھا کہ کتابوں کے نام لکھو، بلکہ اصل کتابیں بغور مطالعہ کرکے متعلقہ تمام عبارت نقل کرنے کو کہا تھا، نالائق خوارج خلیفہٴ برحق سیدنا حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہ کا کفر نعوذ باللہ منہ قرآن کریم سے ثابت کیا کرتے تھے کیا کوئی خارجی اِنِ الْحُکْمُ اِلاَّ لِلّٰہِ لکھ کر قرآن کریم لکھ دے اور بزعم خود یہ سمجھے بیٹھے کہ ہم نے کفر ثابت کردیا تو کیا آپ ایسے خبیث خارجی کی کمر ٹھوک کر شاباشی دینے کو تیار ہیں؟ آپ نے جو عبارات نقل کی ہیں، پہلی ہی عبارت سے معلوم ہوگیا کہ اب تک اصل کتابیں آپ نے نہیں دیکھیں، بلکہ کسی باطل پرست کی کتاب پر آپ نے اعتماد کررکھا ہے، پھر آپ لکھتے ہیں کہ میرے خیال میں ان کے لکھنے والے اسلام سے خارج ہیں، اس سلسلہ میں عرض ہے کہ جناب کے خیال کی شرعی حیثیت کیا ہے؟ پہلے اس کو واضح کردیں، باقی اگر آپ کو اپنے متعلق آخرت کی جواب دہی کا احساس ہے اور علمائے دیوبند کے متعلق زبان کھولنا بھی ضروری سمجھتے ہوں تو ہمارا مشورہ یہ ہے کہ ”عباراتِ اکابر“ چھوٹی سی کتاب ہے، اس کا مطالعہ کرلیں اور اس کے بعد مصنف کتاب حضرت مولانا سرفراز صفدر صاحب مدظلہ گوجراں والا پاکستان سے وقت لے لیں اور ان کے سامنے بیٹھ کر اصل کتابوں کو سامنے رکھ کر اچھی طرح سمجھ لیں اس کے بعد زبان کو کھولیں تو بہتر ہے۔
Talhah
07-03-2008, 04:57 AM
Jazakallah, brother!
So, it means that all (or atleast most of) the allegations against HAdhrat MAulana are false and incorrect--Is it? Well, i saw the title, of an "Ahl-e-HAdith" book, which siad "MAulana Sarfaraz K.S. Apni Tasaneef kay Aiynay main--Ayna JAb un ko Dikhaya to Bura Maan Gay". But i think that all these are Salafi lies.
Wassalaam
Jazakallah, brother!
So, it means that all (or atleast most of) the allegations against HAdhrat MAulana are false and incorrect--Is it? Well, i saw the title, of an "Ahl-e-HAdith" book, which siad "MAulana Sarfaraz K.S. Apni Tasaneef kay Aiynay main--Ayna JAb un ko Dikhaya to Bura Maan Gay". But i think that all these are Salafi lies.
Wassalaam
Shaykh has written many books about ghayr-Muqallidins so he is not liked by them. When they could not refute his books, they started personal attacks.
The above books are refuted, get these two books:
1. "Asri Sahab Ka Majzubana Wawaila", is the reply to "Mawlana Sarfraz Apni Tasanif Kay Aina Main".
2. "Taswir Bari Saf Hai, Sabhi Jan Gaye." and this is the reply to "Aina Un Ko Dikhaya Tou Bura Man Gaye".
These two books are written by Mawlana Hafiz Abdul Quddus Khan Qaran, son of Shaykh Sarfraz, as Shaykh is too elderly to write a reply.
Read the above books and find for yourself the "intellectual state" of ghayr-Muqallidins.
Link to his books:
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=32700&highlight=safdar
mospike
07-03-2008, 06:09 AM
May Allah grant Moulana Sarfaraz Khan strength and good healyh.
Mufti Ilyas has translated many of Hazrats books and Mashallah one can see Hazrat interlectual strength through them.
Definately Hazrat is a protector and defender of the Haq.....
It's good to hear that Hazrats sone are following in his path.
Sunni Muslim
07-03-2008, 02:10 PM
Shaykh has written many books about ghair-Muqallideens so he is not liked by them. When they could not refute his books, they started personal attacks.
The above books are refuted, get these two books:
1. "Asri Sahab Ka Majzoobana Wawaila", is the reply to "Mawlana Sarfraz Apni Tasaneef Kay Aina Main".
2. "Tasweer Bari Saaf Hai, Sabhi Jaan Gaye." and this is the reply to "Aina Un Ko Dikhaya Tou Bura Maan Gaye".
These two books are written by Mawlana Hafiz Abdul Quddus Khan Qaran, son of Shaykh Sarfraz, as Shaykh is too elderly to write a reply.
Read the above books and find for yourself the "intellectual state" of ghair-Muqallideens.
Mashallah! Has anyone scanned these books up anywhere? This should be done if not done already. You see the ghayr muqallid fanatic called Abu Alqama at ah ya.org - promotes attacks against the Mawlana and relies on the works mentioned above.
Shukran
Sunni Muslim
07-03-2008, 02:12 PM
May Allah grant Moulana Sarfaraz Khan strength and good healyh.
Mufti Ilyas has translated many of Hazrats books and Mashallah one can see Hazrat interlectual strength through them.
Definately Hazrat is a protector and defender of the Haq.....
It's good to hear that Hazrats sone are following in his path.
You are saying they are also in English? If so, what titles and where can i get them from? Shukran.
not known
07-03-2008, 03:04 PM
Mashallah! Has anyone scanned these books up anywhere? This should be done if not done already.
yes i feel the same, i need those books and i think i cannot find those books here.. can any body confirm me that books on qair muqallids written by pak ulema can be found in darul uloom deoband, so that i can get them easily
True Life
07-03-2008, 09:10 PM
Salam
Please people don't get lazy about buying books that are actually worth it, just because of internet access.
Was salam
Mashallah! Has anyone scanned these books up anywhere? This should be done if not done already. You see the ghayr muqallid fanatic called Abu Alqama at ah ya.org - promotes attacks against the Mawlana and relies on the works mentioned above.
Shukran
:salam:
I don't have these books with me right now, but I will see if I can get them from Pakistan and then scan them.
You are saying they are also in English? If so, what titles and where can i get them from? Shukran.
I am only aware of Rah-e-Sunnat being translated into English.
http://www.zamzampub.com/pathsunnat_english.html
Talhah
26-03-2008, 07:59 AM
Shaykh has written many books about ghair-Muqallideens so he is not liked by them. When they could not refute his books, they started personal attacks.
The above books are refuted, get these two books:
1. "Asri Sahab Ka Majzoobana Wawaila", is the reply to "Mawlana Sarfraz Apni Tasaneef Kay Aina Main".
2. "Tasweer Bari Saaf Hai, Sabhi Jaan Gaye." and this is the reply to "Aina Un Ko Dikhaya Tou Bura Maan Gaye".
These two books are written by Mawlana Hafiz Abdul Quddus Khan Qaran, son of Shaykh Sarfraz, as Shaykh is too elderly to write a reply.
Read the above books and find for yourself the "intellectual state" of ghair-Muqallideens.
JAzakallah for the title of the books!
There was another book written by Irshad-ul-haq Atharii, by the name "Ahadith-e-Hidayah", which attacked the HAnafi Fiqh book, Hidayah, alleging that the Ahadith mentioned in it are mostly fabricated. Is there a book written to its response? As is Futuhat-e-Safdar, in RAdd-e-Ghayr Muqallidin, written by Allamah Sahib (Safdar Sahib)?
Wassalaam
JAzakallah for the title of the books!
There was another book written by Athari As-Salafi, by the name "Ahadith-e-Hidayah", which attacked the HAnafi Fiqh book, Hidayah, alleging that the Ahadith mentioned in it are mostly fabricated. Is there a book written to its response? As is Futuhat-e-Safdar, in RAdd-e-Ghayr Muqallidin, written by Allamah Sahib (Safdar Sahib)?
Wassalaam
Shaykh has written a book called Maqam-i-Abi Hanifa, and at the end of that book, he answered some of the allegations against Hidayah.
Also you can get Bukhari Sharif Ghayr Muqallidin Ki Nazar Main.
Futuhat-e-Safdar is by Mawlana Amin Safdar Okarvi (may Allah have mercy on him). Mawlana Amin was a student of Shaykh Sarfraz.
Talhah
27-03-2008, 03:53 PM
Shaykh has written a book called Maqam-e-Abi Hanifa, and at the end of that book, he answered some of the allegations against Hidayah.
Also you can get Bukhari Shareef Ghayr Muqallideen Ki Nazar Main.
Futuhat-e-Safdar is by Mawlana Ameen Safdar Okarvi [r.h]. Mawlana Ameen was a student of Shaykh Sarfraz.
Jazakallah
So plz can u summarize the answers to the allegations against the latter (Hidayah).
Jazakallah
So plz can u summarize the answers to the allegations against the latter (Hidayah).
:salam:
It won't be possible to do that here as its quite lengthy, nor do I know which specific allegation you are referring to as there are many. I suggest you get that book.
And as far as the link that you posted about the issue of Mullah Ali Qari (may Allah have mercy on him) and Hadhir Nadhr, then Shaykh has written a book named, Mullah Ali Qari Aur Masla Ilm-i-Ghayb Wa Hadhir Nadhir. InshAllah I will scan that book and post it online. You will be able to see what Mullah Ali Qari had to say about people who believe in Hadhir Nazir and Kuli Ilm-i-Ghayb.
Talhah
28-03-2008, 07:27 AM
:salam:
It won't be possible to do that here as its quite lengthy, nor do I know which specific allegation you are referring to as there are many. I suggest you get that book.
And as far as the link that you posted about the issue of Mullah Ali Qari [r.h] and Hazir Nazir, then Shaykh has written a book named, Mullah Ali Qari Aur Masla Ilm-e-Ghayb Wa Hazir Nazir. InshAllah I will scan that book and post it online. You will be able to see what Mullah Ali Qari had to say about people who believe in Hazir Nazir and Kul Ilm-e-Ghayb.
So, will u scan it on your shared-files website?
So, will u scan it on your shared-files website?
Mullah Ali Qari wa Masla Hazir Nazir.
You can download it here:
http://www.4shared.com/file/42278830/5d4dca29/Mullah_Ali_Qari_wa_Masla_Hazir_Nazir.html?dirPwdVe rified=fa109d20
Talhah
30-03-2008, 01:04 PM
Mullah Ali Qari wa Masla Hazir Nazir.
You can download it here:
http://www.4shared.com/file/42278830/5d4dca29/Mullah_Ali_Qari_wa_Masla_Hazir_Nazir.html?dirPwdVe rified=fa109d20
Jazakallah
Well, regarding thew Ilm-ul-Ghyab issue, i wanted to ask u that is this Mas'alah a Istalahi one--As said by some?
Wassalaam
Jazakallah
Well, regarding thew Ilm-ul-Ghyab issue, i wanted to discuss with u that is this Mas'alah a Istalahi one--As said by some including Mufti Ibn Adam and, according to a source, by Mufti RAfi' Uthmani?
Wassalaam
:ws:
What do you mean by Istalahi?
Imam Rashid Ahmed Gangohi (may Allah have mercy on him) has mentioned in Fatawa Rashidia that anyone who believe that Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) had full [kull] knowledge of ghayb, that is from the first day till people enter Jannah or Jahannam, then this belief is shirk and that person is outside the fold of Islam. This belief is contrary to many ayats of the Quran, mutawattir ahadith and belief of Sahaba and Salaf. And if a person call on Prophet with the belief that He can hear from far and everyone at the same time, then this is also shirk. If someone says "Ya Rasul Allah", with the intention of durud and believe that angels take the durud, then it is allowed. Qasim al-Ulum Mawlana Nanotwi (may Allah have mercy on him) has given the similiar fatwa.
Here are some excerpts from Fatawa Rashidia:
تو خلاف اس عقيده كے كرنا كه انبيأ سب غيوب كو جانتے هيں شرک قبيح جلى هووے گا ـپس ايے عقيدے والا مشرک هواـ اور جب انبيأ كو علم غيب نهيں تو يارسول اللّه كہناناجائز هوگا اگر يه عقيده كركے كهے كه وه دور سے سنتے هيں ـ البته اگر اس كلمه كو درودشريف كے ضمن ميں كہے اور يه عقيده كرے كه ملائكه اس درود شريف كو آپكے پيش عرض كرتے هيں تو درست هے ـ
tazkiyyah
30-03-2008, 06:54 PM
I think the problem is that Shirk gradually crept into the previous religions subtly.
Normally the first thing was to attribute Knowledge of our events to noble prophets/saints.
Then they said those saints can see us and hear us at all times
Then they said that they can do whatsoever they like in the cosmos.
Ilm/Qudrah and hey presto shirk begins to emerge.
Talhah
01-04-2008, 03:56 PM
:ws:
What do you mean by Istalahi?
Imam Rashid Ahmed Gangohi [r.h] has mentioned in Fatawa Rasheedia that anyone who believe that Prophet [s.a.w] had full [kull] knowledge of ghayb, that is from the first day till people enter Jannah or Jahannam, then this belief is shirk and that person is outside the fold of Islam. This belief is contrary to many ayats of the Quran, Mutawattir hadiths and belief of Sahaba and Salaf. And if a person call on Prophet [s.a.w] with the belief that He can hear from far and everyone at the same time, then this is also shirk. If someone says "Ya Rasool Allah", with the intention of durood and believe that angels take the durood, then it is allowed. Qasim al-Uloom Mawlana Nanotwi [r.h] has given the similiar fatwa.
Here are some excerpts from Fatawa Rasheedia:
تو خلاف اس عقيده كے كرنا كه انبيأ سب غيوب كو جانتے هيں شرک قبيح جلى هووے گا ـ
پس ايے عقيدے والا مشرک هواـ اور جب انبيأ كو علم غيب نهيں تو يارسول اللّه كہنا
ناجائز هوگا اگر يه عقيده كركے كهے كه وه دور سے سنتے هيں ـ البته اگر اس كلمه كو درود
شريف كے ضمن ميں كہے اور يه عقيده كرے كه ملائكه اس درود شريف كو آپ
كے پيش عرض كرتے هيں تو درست هے ـ
Jazakallah
Now, we return back to the issue of Hidayah: Actually, i came across the book, i mentioned, written by Maulana Athrai, entitled as "Ahadith-e-Hidayah". It quoted some ahadith from Hidayah and alleged that Allamah li Qari (rh) and Allamah Ibn HAjar (rh) (and some other Muhaddithin) had decared them to be Mawdhu'. It also said that the Isnad of the Ahadith r not given in the Book which further adds to the suspicion that the AHadith mentioned on the latter are Fabricated. It also quoted Hadhrat Safdar (db) saying Farz kijeyay k agar Hidayah main Man Garath Hadithain hain Bhi.." [Maqam-e-Abu Hanifah] So the Ghayr Muqallidin concleded by this statement that MAulana Mausuf also agrees that Hidayah Does contains fabricated Ahadith....?
Ali al-Hanafi
01-04-2008, 04:23 PM
:salam:
Jazakallah
Now, we return back to the issue of Hidayah: Actually, i came across the book, i mentioned, written by Maulana Athrai, entitled as "Ahadith-e-Hidayah". It quoted some ahadith from Hidayah and alleged that Allamah li Qari (rh) and Allamah Ibn HAjar (rh) (and some other Muhaddithin) had decared them to be Mawdhu'. It also said that the Isnad of the Ahadith r not given in the Book which further adds to the suspicion that the AHadith mentioned on the latter are Fabricated.
Would it be possible if you could mention those Ahadith?
It also quoted Hadhrat Safdar (db) saying Farz kijeyay k agar Hidayah main Man Garath Hadithain hain Bhi.." [Maqam-e-Abu Hanifah] So the Ghayr Muqallidin concleded by this statement that MAulana Mausuf also agrees that Hidayah Does contains fabricated Ahadith....?
The words Farz kijeyay k are the Urdu equivilent of "Even if we suppose/assume" and how the Ghayr Muqallid Alim has inferred from this that Allamah Sarfraz Khan (damat barakatuhum) concedes that there are fabricated Ahadith in Hidayah is unbelievable. What about when Allah says in the Qur'an to the effect that, if there was more than one God there would be much corruption? Does that mean that Allah concedes that there is more than one God? Naudhubillah!!!!!!!!!
Jazakallah
Now, we return back to the issue of Hidayah: Actually, i came across the book, i mentioned, written by Maulana Athrai, entitled as "Ahadith-e-Hidayah". It quoted some ahadith from Hidayah and alleged that Allamah li Qari (rh) and Allamah Ibn HAjar (rh) (and some other Muhaddithin) had decared them to be Mawdhu'. It also said that the Isnad of the Ahadith r not given in the Book which further adds to the suspicion that the AHadith mentioned on the latter are Fabricated. It also quoted Hadhrat Safdar (db) saying Farz kijeyay k agar Hidayah main Man Garath Hadithain hain Bhi.." [Maqam-e-Abu Hanifah] So the Ghayr Muqallidin concleded by this statement that MAulana Mausuf also agrees that Hidayah Does contains fabricated Ahadith....?
:salam:
Shaykh Sarfraz mentioned that even if we assume that there are weak hadiths in Hidayah, then does this mean we start to criticize the author and get rid of the book?
He said that there is a hadith in Mishkaat which is mawdu according to majority of scholars. There are mawdu hadiths in Ahya al-Uloom and Ghunyat al-Talibin. There are many mawdu hadiths in Mustadrik al-Hakim. According to Hafiz ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him)there are many munkar ahadith in Sunan ibn Majah. Hafiz Iraqi (may Allah have mercy on him)mentioned that there are nice mawdu ahadith inMusnad Ahmad while Allamah ibn Jawzi (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned 15 mawdu hadiths in Musnad Ahmad. Hafiz ibn Kathir, Allamah Mizi (may Allah have mercy on them) and others have mantioned that there is a hadith in Sunan abu Dawud that is mawdu. Ghayr Muqallidin should stop using all the above mentioned books as they contain some mawdu ahadith.
Shaykh ul-Kul of ghayr Muqallidin Mawlana Sayyid Nazir Hussain used to give dars of Hidayah.
Talhah
02-04-2008, 04:33 PM
WELL, yes, i agree that all of their claims were not very strong-- they said that Hidayah doesnt contains Isnad (which, according to them, further adds to the suspicion of the Ahadith, in it, being Fabricated) and caomparing to it, the Sahah Sittah books does contain the Isnad, but i dont think do that this is a strong claim, either.
Well, what sort of allegations were answered by Maulana Mausuf?...Can u list some of them, Bro. Khanbaba?
WELL, yes, i agree that all of their claims were not very strong-- they said that Hidayah doesnt contains Isnad (which, according to them, further adds to the suspicion of the Ahadith, in it, being Fabricated) and caomparing to it, the Sahah Sittah books does contain the Isnad, but i dont think do that this is a strong claim, either.
Well, what sort of allegations were answered by Maulana Mausuf?...Can u list some of them, Bro. Khanbaba?
Maqam-e-Abi Hanifa is about Imam Abu Hanifa (may Allah have mercy on him) and not Hidayah, but there is one chapter in there which deals briefly with the issue of Hidayah. One of the objection was made over a poem in Hidayah that this book is like Quran, as in how Quran abrogated Torah and Injil, Hidayah has cancelled/abrogated all other books of of hadith and Shari'a. Actually, the word was fiqh but ghayr Muqallidin changed it to sharh [Shari'a]. Shaykh explained that what it means is that Hidayah is one of its kind book and its misal is not found in 4 madhabs. Its tashbih with the Quran in abrogation is just majazi. I would suggest you get the book.
Talhah
02-04-2008, 09:21 PM
Maqam-e-Abi Hanifa is about Imam Abu Hanifa [r.h] and not Hidayah, but there is one chapter in there which deals briefly with the issue of Hidayah. One of the objection was made over a poem in Hidayah that this book is like Quran, as in how Quran abrogated Torah and Injeel, Hidayah has cancelled/abrogated all other books of of hadith and sharia. Actually, the word was fiqh but ghayr Muqallideen changed it to sharh [shariah]. Shaykh explained that what it means is that Hidayah is one of its kind book and its misaal is not found in 4 madhabs. Its tashbeeh with the Quran in abrogation is just majazi. I would suggest you get the book.
Jazakallah
Well, i will try to get the book, but actually, i very lazy at book reading :cheesygri
Wassalaam
Jazakallah
Well, i will try to get the book, but actually, i am poor in the book-reading-issue:cheesygri
Wassalaam
Some of the books are available here to download:
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showpost.php?p=279478&postcount=5
Talhah
04-04-2008, 06:42 PM
Some of the books are available here to download:
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showpost.php?p=279478&postcount=5
Jazakallah, brother
Talhah
05-04-2008, 03:31 PM
Well, how is Maulana Sahibs Tark Qirat Khalf-ul-Imam? Have u read it?
Jazakallah
Now, we return back to the issue of Hidayah: Actually, i came across the book, i mentioned, written by Maulana Athrai, entitled as "Ahadith-e-Hidayah". It quoted some ahadith from Hidayah and alleged that Allamah li Qari (rh) and Allamah Ibn HAjar (rh) (and some other Muhaddithin) had decared them to be Mawdhu'. It also said that the Isnad of the Ahadith r not given in the Book which further adds to the suspicion that the AHadith mentioned on the latter are Fabricated. It also quoted Hadhrat Safdar (db) saying Farz kijeyay k agar Hidayah main Man Garath Hadithain hain Bhi.." [Maqam-e-Abu Hanifah] So the Ghayr Muqallidin concleded by this statement that MAulana Mausuf also agrees that Hidayah Does contains fabricated Ahadith....?
Well, a question which stucks my mind is that the beleifs about Ilm-ul-Ghayb and Hazir o Nazir r Kufr then why r not the believers (of such beliefs) Kaafir?
Talhah
05-04-2008, 04:18 PM
i would like to ask u that have u read Allamah Manzur Nu'mani's Faislah kun Munazra (In the radd od Barelvis) and Irani Inqalab, Imam Khomeni ar Shi'at (Written against the Sh'ahs)? If yes, then how r they? i have just read Hadhrat Maulana's (rh) Mu'arif-ul-Hadith, which i found to be very good.
:salam:
Well, how is Maulana Sahibs Tark Qirat Khalf-ul-Imam? Have u read it?
No, I havent read it yet but I have heard quite alot of prise about it. Allamah Sarfraz mentioned that after I wrote this book, Allamah Khair Muhammad Jallandhary (may Allah have mercy on him). senior khalifa of Hakim ul-Ummat (may Allah have mercy on him), founder of Jamia Khayr ul-Madaris, Multan and first head of Wafaq ul-Madaris al-Arabia ] came to me and said that I have debated ghayr Muqallideen on Fatiha Khalf al-Imam many times. But I still had some doubts in my heart. After I read this book, now all my doubts have been cleared.
Originally Posted by Talhah:
Also, i would like to ask u that have u read Allamah Manzur Nu'mani's Faislah kun Munazra (In the radd od Barelvis) and Irani Inqalab, Imam Khomeni ar Shi'at (Written against the Sh'ahs)? If yes, then how r they? i have just read Hadhrat Maulana's (rh) Mu'arif-ul-Hadith, which i found to be very good.
You can read Faisla Kun Munazra (http://www.4shared.com/file/37511309/b4596283/Faisla_Kun_Munazera_-_Mawlana_Naumani.html?dirPwdVerified=fa109d20) of Mawlana Naumani [r.h] here.
And you can read Iranian Revolution (http://www.kr-hcy.com/shia/books/mmnomani/index.shtml) here. It is a very well researched book. Mawlana Manzoor Ahmed Naumani (may Allah have mercy on him) was probably the first one to stand up to Khomeni's fitna, when it was considered a crime to speak up against Khomeni. At that time he was very elderly and had stop writing. But he had to change his mind to write one last book, as he himself mentioned, "I felt that it was my religious duty as well as moral obligation to my co-religionists to try, to the best of my capacity, to acquaint them with the real position with regard to Khomeini, and the revolution engineered by him and with the Shi’ite faith with special reference to the doctrine of Imamate for it forms the religious and intellectual foundation of the Iranian Revolution."
Originally Posted by Talhah:
Well, a question which stucks my mind is that the beleifs about Ilm-ul-Ghayb and Hazir o Nazir r Kufr then why r not the believers (of such beliefs) Kaafir?
I have already quoted the fatwa of Imam Rashid Ahmed Gangohi (may Allah have mercy on him) on those who hold above mentioned beliefs. Similar fatwas can be found in major books of fiqh such as Bahr al-Raqaiq, Fatawa Alamgiri, Fatawa Qadi Khan, Fatawa Bazzaziya, etc.
Also which quotes from Ahl-us-Sunnah aur Ahl-e-Bid'ah ki Payhchaan you doubts about? Allamah Sarfraz Khan has mentioned that Mawlana Ahmed Raza Khan did lafzi tahrif in his Urdu translation of the Quran. His student Mawlana Naeem Muradabadi wrote tasfir using the translation of Mawlana Ahmed Raza Khan. At the request of Mufti Muhammed Shafi, Allamah Sarfraz wrote "Tanqid-i-Matim ba Tasfir-e-Naeem" and showed that at many places this tafsir is contrary to the the authentic tasafirs of early scholars. This tranlation and and tafseer is banned in many Arab countries such as U.A.E, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Sunni Areas of Iran and tribal Areas, etc.
Nu'ayman ibn Amr
06-04-2008, 08:58 PM
Also, i would like to ask u that have u read Allamah Manzur Nu'mani's Faislah kun Munazra (In the radd od Barelvis) and Irani Inqalab, Imam Khomeni ar Shi'at (Written against the Sh'ahs)? If yes, then how r they? i have just read Hadhrat Maulana's (rh) Mu'arif-ul-Hadith, which i found to be very good.
:salam:
Hadhrat Mawlana Manzur Nu'mani's :rahim: Faysla Kun Munazarah is a refutation/clarification of Mawlana Ahmad Ridha Khan's Hussam al-Haramayn. In it, he completely rips apart the Mawlana's allegations against the Elders of Deoband and his takfir of them. He exposes the shocking level of deceit and dishonesty employed in Mawlana Ahmad Ridha Khan's work.
Mufti Taqi 'Uthmani sahib has heavily praised this book. Infact, if I remember correctly, he wrote that from all the books that he has studied on this issue, he found Faysla Kun Munazarah the most beneficial.
Talhah
07-04-2008, 04:22 AM
...I have already quoted the fatwa of Imam Rashid Ahmed Gangohi [r.h] on those who hold above mentioned beliefs. Similar fatwas can be found in major books of fiqh such as Bahr al-Raqaiq, Fatawa Alamgeri, Fatawa Qadi Khan, Fatawa Bazzaziya, etc.
Jazakallah brother!
What i was asking, here, was that when these beleifs r kufr then why r not the beleivers r not classified as Kafirs?
Talhah
07-04-2008, 04:31 AM
:salam:
Hadhrat Mawlana Manzur Nu'mani's :rahim: Faysla Kun Munazarah is a refutation/clarification of Mawlana Ahmad Ridha Khan's Hussam al-Haramayn. In it, he completely rips apart the Mawlana's allegations against the Elders of Deoband and his takfir of them. He exposes the shocking level of deceit and dishonesty employed in Mawlana Ahmad Ridha Khan's work.
Mufti Taqi 'Uthmani sahib has heavily praised this book. Infact, if I remember correctly, he wrote that from all the books that he has studied on this issue, he found Faysla Kun Munazarah the most beneficial.
Jazakallah brother!
Talhah
07-04-2008, 04:26 PM
Well i could not access the Haq char Yar website--is there a problem with the webpage? However, i would like to know that is the book by Maulana Manzur Nu'mani just an exposition of the Shi'i beiefs or is it Refutation, as well? And, do MAulana Sahib regard the Shi'as as Kafirs?
Well i could not access the Haq char Yar website--is there a problem with the webpage? However, i would like to know that is the book by Maulana Manzur Nu'mani just an exposition of the Shi'i beiefs or is it Refutation, as well? And, do MAulana Sahib regard the Shi'as as Kafirs?
I believe the site is banned in Pakistan. You can access the site by using anonymous proxy like www.anonymouse.org.
Below are some scans from the Shia-Sunni Ikhtelafat - Afadaat Allamah Naumani , where he clearly mentioned that Shias are outside the fold of Islam. Infact, Mawlana Naumani also menions that Isna Ashris are more deviant than the Qadyanis. Shias are also [I]munkar of Finality of the Prophethood like the Qadyanis, since they believe that their Imams are directly appointed by Allah. It is fard to follow the Imams. Imams receive Wahi. Imams have complete knowledge of unseen. Imams can change the laws of Sharia. Imams are superior to most of the Prophets. He has also listed tons of differences between both religions . [I]Iranian Revolution is mostly an exposition than refutation. Mawlana has written another book, Shia Itna-e-Ashri Aur Aqeeda Tehreef-e-Quran, which is also available on HCY.
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia1-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia2-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia3-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia4-1.jpg
Khomenism Aur Islam (http://www.kr-hcy.com/khomani/index.shtml) by Allamah Zia-ur-Rahman Faruqi Shahid (may Allah have mercy on him) is also worth reading.
Jazakallah brother!
What i was asking, here, was that when these beleifs r kufr then why r not the beleivers r not classified as Kafirs?
Well, the book contained some other astonishing details abut Raza khan and Barelvi beleifs... And then, in the end, the author quoted some graet, correct Fatwas from Raza Sahib's books, so the question arises that was Raza Khan a guided person (and afterwards, misquoted) or was he a deviated person (as we think)?
Wassalaam
:salam:
If anyone hold beliefs that are kufar, then he will be labelled a kafir. Some of the beliefs that are kufar:
1. Belief that Prophets and Awliya have the complete knowledge of unseen and nothing in the whole Universe is hidden from them.
2. Belief that Prophets and Awliya are always Hadhir Nadhir. They can hear you directly no matter where you call them from. And then they come to help you [with Ruh or Physically]. If ones call upon them with the intention of tawassul, love or the believe that angels our dua to them, then its permissible. But careful amongst the Fuqaha don't allow this among the laymen.
3. Belief that Prophet is physical Nur and not a Bashr. Know that Prophet was a Bashr but Nur in his sifaat and His teachings were Nur.
4. To slaughter animals for anyone beside Allah. It is also kufar to slaughter an animal for tazeem [respect] of Awliya even if you say the name of Allah when slaughtering it.
Beside that there is alot of filth in the books of Mawlana Ahmed Raza Khan. He also insulted our mother Hadhrat Ayisha (may Allah be pelased with her) in Haqaiq-e-Bakshish , III:37. He talks about the "tight dress" and "husan" of Hadhat Ayisha.
You can also read Molwi Ahmed Radha Khan among the Arab Ulama (http://zakariyya.wordpress.com/2007/04/02/molwi-ahmed-radha-khan-among-the-arab-ulama/).
Talhah
12-04-2008, 05:30 AM
:salam:
If anyone hold beliefs that are kufar, then he will be labelled a kafir. Some of the beliefs that are kufar:
1. Belief that Prophets and Awliya have the complete knowledge of unseen and nothing in the whole Universe is hidden from them.
2. Belief that Prophets and Awliya are always Hazir Nazir. They can hear you directly no matter where you call them from. And then they come to help you [with Rooh or Physically]. If ones call upon them with the intention of tawassul, love or the believe that angels our dua to them, then its permissible. But careful amongst the Fuqaha don't allow this among the laymen.
3. Belief that Prophet [s.a.w] is physical Noor and not a Bashr. Prophet [s.a.w] was a Bashr but Noor in his sifaat and His teachings were Noor.
4. To slaughter animals for anyone beside Allah. It is also kufar to slaughter an animal for tazeem [respect] of Awliya even if you say the name of Allah when slaughtering it.
Beside that there is alot of filth in the books of Mawlana Ahmed Raza Khan. He also insulted our mother Hazrat Ayesha [r.h] in Haqaiq-e-Bakshish , vol III page 37. He talks about the "tight dress" and "husan" of Hazrat Ayesha [r.h].
You can also read Molwi Ahmed Radha Khan among the Arab Ulama (http://zakariyya.wordpress.com/2007/04/02/molwi-ahmed-radha-khan-among-the-arab-ulama/).
Jazakalah Brother!
Well, i was trying to ask u that why r ,then, the ******** not labeled as Kafirs?
And those Ash'ar of Raza Khan, of which u were talking about, r they eally by Rza Khan and directed towards Mother Aa'ishah? What does the Raza Khanis say about it?
Wassalaam
Talhah
12-04-2008, 05:41 AM
I believe the site is banned in Pakistan. You can access the site by using anonymous proxy like www.anonymouse.org.
Below are some scans from the Shia-Sunni Ikhtelafaat - Afadaat Allamah Naumani [r.h], where he clearly mentioned that Shias are outside the fold of Islam. Infact, Mawlana Naumani also menions that Isna Ashris are more deviant than the Qadyanis. Shias are also [I]munkar of Finality of the Prophethood like the Qadyanis, since they believe that their Imams are directly appointed by Allah. It is fard to follow the Imams. Imams receive Wahi. Imams have complete knowledge of unseen. Imams can change the laws of Sharia. Imams are superior to most of the Prophets. He has also listed tons of differences between both religions . [I]Iranian Revolution is mostly an exposition than refutation. Mawlana has written another book, Shia Itna-e-Ashri Aur Aqeeda Tehreef-e-Quran, which is also available on HCY.
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia1-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia2-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia3-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia4-1.jpg
Khomenism Aur Islam (http://www.kr-hcy.com/khomani/index.shtml) by Allamah Zia-ur-Rahman Farooqi shaheed [r.h] is also worth reading.
Jazakallah
Well yes, the Shi'ahs r actually the Usaads and Imams of the Qadiyanis--The Qadiyanis claimed just a single False Prophet, recently, but the Shiahs had already claimed (hundreds of years before) 12 False Prphets! And, the Shiahs also permit the Zina (permissibilty of Mut'a).:mad:
(Well, umust be nowing all this much better than me1:cheesygri )
Wassalaam
Well, cam u also, plz, give a list of Allamah Sarfaraz's books on te ghayr Muqallidin?
And, has Allamah Sahib written any books on the Shi'ism?
Wassalaam
Jazakalah Brother!
Well, i was trying to ask u that why r ,then, the ******** not labeled as Kafirs?
And those Ash'ar of Raza Khan, of which u were talking about, r they eally by Rza Khan and directed towards Mother Aa'ishah? What does the Raza Khanis say about it?
Wassalaam
:salam:
Know that there are different type of Barelwis, so they can't be labelled all under one category. Here is a fatwa from Darul Uloom Deoband answering a question about the permissibility of praying behind a Beralwi imam:
(1) If he is only Bidati and does not hold beliefs that lead one to Kufr (infidelity) then salah will be valid behind him but will be makrooh (undesirable).
(2) The Barelvi people are bent to twist and distort the texts, written by Ulama of Ahlus Sunnah wal-Jamaah Ulama of Deoband, and regard them as kafir. While the Ulama of Deoband strictly avoid to term anyone as kafir and try as much as possible to give a good explanation to every act or saying of a Muslim. The Barelvis consider it compulsory to adopt the anti-sunnat issues as symbol of their sect, while the Ulama of Deoband reject all these innovations. For details, please see Mutala-e-Barelviat by Allama Dr Khalid Mahmood, Ghalat Fahmiyon ka Izalah, Tuhfatul Jannah Liahlis Sunnah, Fatawa Rahimia v 1, 6, Fatawa Mahmoodiah etc.
http://darulifta-deoband.org/viewfatwa.jsp?ID=318
As far as the ash'ar, then these are in present in Haqaiq-i-Bakshish , III:37. A Beralwi scholar by the name of Sayyid Zahir-ud-Qadri from Kanpur, India wrote a book called "Ulama-i-Ahl-i-Sunnat say Ruh Ala-Hadhrat ki Faryad." In that book he urged the Barelwi scholars and publishers to take out anything from the books of Mawlana Ahmed Raza Khan that is questionable and disturbing. He listed many thing, which according to him will take any intellecutal Muslim away from Ahmed Raza Khan. He listed these things among why intellectual Muslims are not impressed by Ahmed Raza Khan. On page 8 on this book he mentions how whole of vol III of Hadaqiq-i-Bakshish was somehow hidden by Beralwi Ulema since it contained the ash'ar insulting Hadhrat Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her). Then he goes on to argue that instead of making the whole of Vol III unavailable from the general public, we should just take out those ash'ar from the book. He also mentions that to counter the argument that Ahmed Raza Khan insulted Hadhrat Aisha and him being labelled a Shia, we should write a book about the virtues of Hadhat Ayisha , as put the name of Ahmed Raza as the author. Then he goes on to say that we should also write a book of Fazail-e-Durud, on the "zawq/style" of Ahmed Raza, because of the claim that Ahmed Raza never wrote anything Fazail-e-Durood. He also mentioned that we should write a book about Sirat al-Nabi to counter the claim that Ahmed Raza never wrote anything on this topic, and his claim for the love of Prophet were just plain slogans. Zahir-ud-Qadri goes on to say that in most of the biographies of Ahmed Raza, it is mentioned that [as a pride] when Ahmed Raza Khan was only 3 years old, one day he was stading at the balcony of his house and only had a long kurta/shirt on. Few prostitues were passing by, so Ahmed Raza covered his eyes with his kurta. On seeing this, those prostitutes said, "Strange, you have covered your eyes but your private parts are naked," so Ahmed Raza Khan replied, "when eyes slip, then the heart slips, and when the heart slips, then private parts slip."He goes on to urge that this should be taken out from all the biographies on Ahmed Raza Khan. He even says that this gives the wrong trying to show that Ahmed Raza was not an expert of Sharia but an expert on Sexuality. For now, I have only listed few things, more will be added later on.
Here are some scans from "Ulama-i-Ahl-e-Sunnat say Ruh Ala-Hadhrat ki Faryad."
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Rooh-e-AlaHazrat1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Rooh-e-AlaHazrat2.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Rooh-e-AlaHazrat3.jpg
Shaykh has written a book on Shias named, Irshad al-Shia, and I will put it up on my site by next week, along with Maqam-i-Abi Hanifa and few others. InshAllah.
His book on ghayr Muqallideen include:
1. Ahsan al-Kalam.
2. Taskin al-Sudur.
3. Al-Kalam al-Mufud.
4. Maqam-i-Abi Hanifa.
5. Sima-i-Mauta
6. Yana'bih [on Tarawih].
7. Taifa-i-Mansurah.
8. Al-Shihab al-Mubin.
9. Umdat ul-Asas.
10. Atib al-Kalam.
You can also refer to "Bukhari Sharif ghayr Muqallidin ki Nazar Main".
Talhah
13-04-2008, 03:47 AM
:salam:
.....His book on ghayr Muqallideen include:
1. Ahsan al-Kalam.
2. Taskeen al-Sudoor.
3. Al-Kalam al-Mufeed.
4. Maqam-e-Abi Hanifa [r.h].
5. Sima-e-Mauta
6. Yanabeeh [on Taraweeh].
7. Taifa-e-Mansurah.
8. Al-Shahab al-Mubeen.
9. Umdat ul-Asaas.
10. Ateeb al-Kalam.
You can also refer to "Bukhari Shareef ghayr Muqallideen ki Nazar Main".
Jazakallah brother!
May Allah Reward you very much! Ameen
Well, plz can u post that what were the abve mentioned books, on the Ghyar Muqallidin, about? And was "Bukhari Shareef.." written by Shaykh, himself? And, who was the spritual Shaykh of the Allamah Sahib?
Jazakallah
Jazakallah brother!
May Allah Reward you very much! Ameen
Well, plz can u post that what were the abve mentioned books, on the Ghyar Muqallidin, about? And was "Bukhari Shareef.." written by Shaykh, himself? And, who was the spritual Shaykh of the Allamah Sahib?
Jazakallah
1. Ahsan al-Kalam - Fatiha Khalf al-Imam.
2. Taskin al-Sudir - Hayat al-Nabi, Tawassul, Life in grave., etc
3. Al-Kalam al-Mufid - Taqlid.
4. Maqam-i-Abi Hanifah - Answers to accusations againt Imam and his high status.
5. Sima-i-Mauta - Can the dead hear?
6. Yana'bih - on Tarawih
7. Taifa-i-Mansurah - What is real meaning of Ahl-e-Hadith? Which is the saved sect?
8. Al-Shihab al-Mubin - Azab-i-Qabar and related issues.
9. Umdat ul-Asas - Issue of talaq.
10. Ateib al-Kalam - Fatiha Khalf al-Imam.
I am not sure if "Bukhari Shareef ghayr Muqallidin ki Nazar Main" is by Shaykh or his son Hafiz Abdul Quddus Khan Qarran.
Allamah Sarfraz is khalifa-i-majzz of Shaykh al-Quran Mawlana Hussain Ali. Mawlana Hussain Ali was the student of Imam Rashid Ahmad Gangohi (may Allah have mercy on him). I believe Mawlana Hussain Ali was khalifa of Hadhrat Khuwaja Usman Damani Naqshbandi (may Allah have mercy on him). Allamah Sayyid Ahmed Raza Binjuri (may Allah have mercy on him) was also bayat to Mawlana Hussain Ali and he learnt tafsir of whole Quran from in just one month.
Here you can see Hadhrat Khuwaja Usman Damani is also in the silsila of Mawlana Zulfiqar Ahmed, see no 35.
http://www.tasawwuf.org/shaykh/silsilah.htm
Talhah
14-04-2008, 05:27 AM
1. Ahsan al-Kalam - Fatiha Khalf al-Imam.
2. Taskeen al-Sudoor - Hayat al-Nabi [s.a.w], Tawassul, Life in grave.
3. Al-Kalam al-Mufeed - Taqleed.
4. Maqam-e-Abi Hanifa [r.h] - Answers to accusations againt Imam and his high status.
5. Sima-e-Mauta - Can the dead hear?
6. Yanabeeh - on Taraweeh
7. Taifa-e-Mansurah - What is real meaning of Ahl-e-Hadith? Which is the saved sect?
8. Al-Shahab al-Mubeen - Azab-e-Qabar and related issues.
9. Umdat ul-Asaas - Issue of talaq.
10. Ateeb al-Kalam - Fatiha Khalf al-Imam.
....
Jazakallah brother!
So, did he write two books on the Fatihah Khalf a-Imam issue?
And, have u read his book on the Taqleed issue--how is that? Has Mufti Taqi Uthamni covered those points in his Taqleed ki Shar'ee Haysiat?
Wassalaam
I believe the site is banned in Pakistan. You can access the site by using anonymous proxy like www.anonymouse.org.
.........
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia1-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia2-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia3-1.jpg
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/Shia4-1.jpg
Khomenism Aur Islam (http://www.kr-hcy.com/khomani/index.shtml) by Allamah Zia-ur-Rahman Farooqi shaheed [r.h] is also worth reading.
Well, i could not download the files from the anonymous website (even an 1.78mb file)--Is there another website? And i wonder that what was the need for Pakistan to bann this website (which defends Islam from the Kufr), when all those filthy websites can be easily accessed!:frown:
Wassalaam
....
Khomenism Aur Islam (http://www.kr-hcy.com/khomani/index.shtml) by Allamah Zia-ur-Rahman Farooqi shaheed [r.h] is also worth reading.
Well, has this book and the book by Allamah Manzur Nu'mani been published by any Pakisani Bookstore (or whatever we call it) such as darul-Isha'ah and Idaratul-Mu'arif?
wassalaam
Jazakallah brother!
So, did he write two books on the Fatihah Khalf a-Imam issue?
And, have u read his book on the Taqleed issue--how is that? Has Mufti Taqi Uthamni covered those points in his Taqleed ki Shar'ee Haysiat?
Wassalaam
Well, i could not download the files from the anonymous website (even an 1.78mb file)--Is there another website? And i wonder that what was the need for Pakistan to bann this website (which defends Islam from the Kufr), when all those filthy websites can be easily accessed!:frown:
Wassalaam
Well, has this book and the book by Allamah Manzur Nu'mani been published by any Pakisani Bookstore (or whatever we call it) such as darul-Isha'ah and Idaratul-Mu'arif?
wassalaam
:salam:
1. Well, I have only read Al-Kalam al-Mufeed, but I believe Atib al-Kalam is not as detailed as Ahsan al-Kalam. Taqleed Ki Shar'i Haysiat is also not as detailed, and I believe it is for beginners. But it was the first book that I read on Taqlid and answered most of my questions. Once you have read that, you can refer to Al-Kalam al-Mufid for more detailed discussion on this topic.
2. You can use proxy to access that site.
3. Khomanism Aur Islam was publised by Idara Ishat al-Ma'arif , Faisalabad. I don't know the publishers for the book by Mawlana Muhammad Manzur Naumani as a friend of mine has borrowed it from me.
Talhah
15-04-2008, 05:45 AM
:salam:
1. Well, I have only read Al-Kalam al-Mufeed, but I believe Ateeb al-Kalam is not as detailed as Ahsan al-Kalam. Taqleed Ki Shar'ee Haysiat is also not as detailed, and I believe it is for beginners. But it was the first book that I read on Taqleed and answered most of my questions. Once you have read that, you can refer to Al-Kalam al-Mufeed for more detailed discussion on this topic.
2. You can use proxy to access that site.
3. Khomanism Aur Islam was publised by Idara Ishat al-Ma'arif , Faisalabad. I don't know the publishers for the book by Mawlana Muhammed Manzur Naumani [r.h] as a friend of mine has borrowed it from me.
Jazakallah brother!
Well, what the proxy, actually, is?
And, approximately of how much pages does the al-kalam al-Mufeed comprises of?
Wassalaam
Jazakallah brother!
Well, what the proxy, actually, is?
And, approximately of how much pages does the al-kalam al-Mufeed comprises of?
Wassalaam
:salam:
Al-Kalam al-Mufeed consists of 341 pages, with 13 different baabs (chapters).
You can go to www.anonymouse.org and use an anonymous proxy.
Talhah
19-04-2008, 02:26 PM
:salam:
Al-Kalam al-Mufeed consists of 341 pages, with 13 different baabs [chapters].
You can go to www.anonymouse.org and use an anonymous proxy.
Salaam
But i told u that i could not download any files thru this site.:rolleyes:
Ali al-Hanafi
17-06-2008, 04:19 PM
:salam:
An English translation of Rah-e-Sunnat is now available:
http://www.zamzampub.com/pathsunnat_english.html
The translation is by, you guessed it Hazrat Mufti A.H. Elias Sahib (damat barakatuhum). Turath Publishing should think about employing Hazrat Mufti Sahib (damat barakatuhum). They'd get things translated a lot quicker if they did!
:salam:
An English translation of Rah-e-Sunnat is now available:
http://www.zamzampub.com/pathsunnat_english.html
The translation is by, you guessed it Hazrat Mufti A.H. Elias Sahib (damat barakatuhum). Turath Publishing should think about employing Hazrat Mufti Sahib (damat barakatuhum). They'd get things translated a lot quicker if they did!
:ws:
The English version of Al-Minhaj al-Wadih - The Path of Sunnat can be download from here. (http://www.4shared.com/file/65184141/a34a34c3/Al-Minhaj_al-Wadih_-_The_Path_of_Sunnat.html?dirPwdVerified=6ea128eb)
Scholarly Contributions Of My Father
by Allamah Zahid al-Rashidi.
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/mag-01.gif
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/mag-01-2.gif
http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i72/khanbaba21/mag-01-3.gif
mustajab
19-12-2008, 03:15 AM
:salam:
An English translation of Rah-e-Sunnat is now available:
http://www.zamzampub.com/pathsunnat_english.html
The translation is by, you guessed it Hazrat Mufti A.H. Elias Sahib (damat barakatuhum). Turath Publishing should think about employing Hazrat Mufti Sahib (damat barakatuhum). They'd get things translated a lot quicker if they did!
:salam:
Link is not working.
Muaz bin jabal
19-12-2008, 03:45 AM
Their website is down.
:salam:
Mufti Zar Wali Khan mentions that my ustaad Muhaddith Allamah Yusuf Binori (may Allah have mercy on him) used to say:
"Ham naam kay Deobandi hain, Sarfraz Khan kaam ka Deobandi hai."
He says that whenever he would hear the name of Allamah Sarfraz Khan Safdar, a smile would appear on his face.
He also mentions that perusal/study (mutaliya) of Safraz Khan Safdar is only next to Allamah Binori as he had more resources available.
Talhah
20-02-2009, 04:49 AM
:salam:
Mufti Zar Wali Khan mentions that my ustaad Muhaddith Allamah Yusuf Binori [r.h] used to say:
"Ham naam kay Deobandi hain, Sarfraz Khan kaam ka Deobandi hai."
He says that whenever he would hear the name of Allamah Sarfraz Khan Safdar, a smile would appear on his face.
He also mentions that perusal/study [mutaliya] of Safraz Khan Safdar is only next to Allamah Binori as he had more resources available.
Assalamu-'alaykum
Brother can u tell me that what is Nataij Inkaar-e-hadis about?
Wasslaam
Abu_Bilal
20-02-2009, 05:00 AM
Assalamu-'alaykum
Brother can u tell me that what is Nataij Inkaar-e-hadis about?
Wasslaam
Walikum-us-salam.
It basically talks about the consequences of negating the hadeeth of Rasoolulah (SAWW). How one goes astray, and goes away from the straight path. It is a good book, but there is an even better book on Inkar-e-Hadis by Mufti Rafi Usmani.
am405
27-02-2009, 03:10 PM
Does anyone know if Allama Sarfaraz Khan Safdar has written a book about the issue of nur and bashar of Sayyiduna Rasulullah (sallallahu alaihi wa sallam)? I am looking for something written by our ulama on this subject, specifically in refutation of the Barelwis' belief.
omar2006
27-02-2009, 03:26 PM
Does anyone know if Allama Sarfaraz Khan Safdar has written a book about the issue of nur and bashar of Sayyiduna Rasulullah (sallallahu alaihi wa sallam)? I am looking for something written by our ulama on this subject, specifically in refutation of the Barelwis' belief.
Noor O Bahsar by Hazrat Allama Sarfaraz Khan Safdar db
http://www.ahlehaq.com/pdf/Noor%20O%20Bashar.pdf
Ahmad_shakeel
27-04-2009, 07:09 PM
http://www.ahlehaq.com/books/Alkalam%20Al%20Mufeed%20Fi%20Asbat%20Ataqleed/1.jpg
To read online or Download
http://www.ahlehaq.com/gm6.html
intoodeep
27-04-2009, 10:31 PM
Noor O Bahsar by Hazrat Allama Sarfaraz Khan Safdar db
http://www.ahlehaq.com/pdf/Noor%20O%20Bashar.pdf
Has that book been translated to English?? if not, i am willing to make a contribution to whoever doe translate it.
ANyone here have any ideas on how we can get it translated?
Ahmad_shakeel
27-04-2009, 10:35 PM
what kind of contribution are you looking forward to
bro if you are serious about that then we can find some good scholar to do so but we will need to pay him some money as well i tried this sometime before but no one is ready to do it for free its sad but i unno what else we can do
Muaz bin jabal
27-04-2009, 10:58 PM
@ahmad
Not really the scholars fault, they after all do need a source of income. We don't give them **** as it is...
@intoodeep
I pray that Allah makes it easy for you and gives you perseverance. I suggest you use Google Docs to collaborate with the person helping you.
Remember Quality over Quantity!
Ahmad_shakeel
27-04-2009, 11:01 PM
i am not blaming any scholar just talking about the situation i do accept the fact that they also need a source of income
intoodeep
28-04-2009, 07:00 PM
what kind of contribution are you looking forward to
bro if you are serious about that then we can find some good scholar to do so but we will need to pay him some money as well i tried this sometime before but no one is ready to do it for free its sad but i unno what else we can do
A Financial contribution. Alhamdulillah its good to see support for my proposal here. Inshallah already a member of this forum is looking for translators who can be of help.
@intoodeep
I pray that Allah makes it easy for you and gives you perseverance. I suggest you use Google Docs to collaborate with the person helping you.
Remember Quality over Quantity!
Bro im not going to be the one translating this! Inshallah will leave to more learned brothers. If you know of anyone we can hire etc then please let me know.
Assalam o alaykum,
If anyone else is willing to contribute financially, please say so and I will contact you through email.
JazakAllah.
Propagating_Haq
10-05-2009, 05:12 PM
which book are you thinking of having transalated?
which book are you thinking of having transalated?
Assalam o alaykum,
At the moment, Noor wa Bashar is in the progress but more books can be translated. It all depends on how much contributions we receive from the brothers. Those who contribute will have a say in picking the books for translation.
Ahmad_shakeel
10-05-2009, 07:25 PM
i was thinking of taskeen as sudoor or al kalam al mufeed
Zubair
10-05-2009, 09:25 PM
Is Sima' Mawta by 'Allama Khan online?
Ma' Salama
Ahmad_shakeel
10-05-2009, 10:11 PM
lol
i am trying to but i dont have this book mamatis wrote an answer to that book and hazrat wrote an answer to that which is scanned but not uploaded coz i am waiting for sama e mouta lets see when they scan if u send me i will scan and upload
intoodeep
10-05-2009, 11:21 PM
cool80,
ALhamdullilah one book (noor wa bashar) is already being translated. It would be good if you can support the next ones.
We have thousands of members on these forum, and it is very cheap to get these books translated. I ask all members of SF to support this effort and earn sadaqah jariyah for themselves.
Brothers who want to donate please get in touch with Khanbaba. At the moment very few brothers are donating. If we can even get 10-20 contributing just a bit we will be able to move mountains.
hope1
11-05-2009, 03:20 AM
cool80,
ALhamdullilah one book (noor wa bashar) is already being translated. It would be good if you can support the next ones.
We have thousands of members on these forum, and it is very cheap to get these books translated. I ask all members of SF to support this effort and earn sadaqah jariyah for themselves.
Brothers who want to donate please get in touch with Khanbaba. At the moment very few brothers are donating. If we can even get 10-20 contributing just a bit we will be able to move mountains.
How can we donate? Paypal?
How can we donate? Paypal?
Assalam o alaykum,
Do you know any potential translators? Answer to your question is Western Union.
Propagating_Haq
11-05-2009, 10:33 PM
it has been a long ambition of mine to have al kalamul mufeed transalated, to such an extent that i even have got ready a panel of 4 scholars to do the job,but unfortanately worldy affairs etc work,are not allowing to get this started. make dua i am trying to get it pushed through everyday.
brothers are requested o contribute to this noble cause,pls contact khanbaba.
True Life
12-05-2009, 12:03 AM
:salam:
http://www.ahlehaq.com/books/Alkalam%20Al%20Mufeed%20Fi%20Asbat%20Ataqleed/1.jpg
To read online or Download
http://www.ahlehaq.com/gm6.htmlThe book is huge. Is in it anything specially written on Taqlid Shaksi? If so, on which page?
Ahmad_shakeel
12-05-2009, 12:06 AM
brother you can read a chapter on taqleed e shaksi from this book
and if you dont want to then go to www.ahlehaq.com/gm.html there are many other books where you can find stuff on taqleed e shaksi for example adila e kamila there is a chapter on taqleed e shaksi in that book other then that there are other books and rasail on that which you can find online in ahlehaq
True Life
12-05-2009, 12:09 AM
:salam:
brother you can read a chapter on taqleed e shaksi from this bookYes, I want it from that book. Excuse me for putting it in the wrong way. Can you tell me the page?
Ahmad_shakeel
12-05-2009, 12:11 AM
you can check the index :lol:
True Life
12-05-2009, 12:14 AM
:salam:
you can check the index :lol:I did already fly over it, but couldn't find anything hinting towards a discussion on Taqlid Shaksi.
Ahmad_shakeel
12-05-2009, 12:21 AM
bro check page 130 baab 5
also check baab 9 on page 172
and check baab 11 on page 239
i think these are the places where you can find stuff on taqlid e shaksi
Assalam o alaykum,
Taskin al-Sudur fi Tahqiq Ahwal al-Mawtah fi Barzakh wa ‘l-Qubur — a detailed discussion on the lives of the prophets in their graves, death, the soul, punishment in the grave, the hearing of the dead, tawassul, istimdad, etc. This book was written at the request of ‘Allamah Yusuf Binnori and Mawlana Mufti Mahmud. It also consists of introductions by almost all senior Deobandi scholars who were alive at the time of its publication. According to Mufti Zar Wali Khan, this book is the most thorough ever written on the topic, and more detailed than what ‘Allamah al-Suyuti and Imam al-Qurtubi have written;
Can be downloaded at the links below:
http://www.ahlehaq.com/aqaid3.html
http://www.ahlehaq.com/books/book-taskeen-us-sudoor-369-p0.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362403/c6a6263d/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_1.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362409/2673cf23/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_2.html
Talhah
18-06-2009, 02:03 PM
Assalam o alaykum,
Taskin al-Sudur fi Tahqiq Ahwal al-Mawtah fi Barzakh wa ‘l-Qubur — a detailed discussion on the lives of the prophets in their graves, death, the soul, punishment in the grave, the hearing of the dead, tawassul, istimdad, etc. This book was written at the request of ‘Allamah Yusuf Binnori and Mawlana Mufti Mahmud. It also consists of introductions by almost all senior Deobandi scholars who were alive at the time of its publication. According to Mufti Zar Wali Khan, this book is the most thorough ever written on the topic, and more detailed than what ‘Allamah al-Suyuti and Imam al-Qurtubi have written;
Can be downloaded at the links below:
http://www.ahlehaq.com/aqaid3.html
http://www.ahlehaq.com/books/book-taskeen-us-sudoor-369-p0.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362403/c6a6263d/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_1.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362409/2673cf23/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_2.html
salaam
jazakallah for posting the link.
wassalaam
salaam
jazakallah brother for posting the link.
wassalaam
Ahmad_shakeel
08-07-2009, 01:57 AM
maulana sadiq kohati (ex ghayr muqallid) accepts Hazrat Allama sarfraz khan safdar rehmatullah in reply to a question asked by Maulana Ilyas Ghuman
go to min 3 50
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqXYFHaL3Ao&feature=related
he says his aqaid in his books are aqaid of ahle sunah
every sunni shd agree with it
True Life
08-07-2009, 01:30 PM
:salam:
maulana sadiq kohati (ex ghayr muqallid) accepts Hazrat Allama sarfraz khan safdar rehmatullah in reply to a question asked by Maulana Ilyas GhumanIt was Maulana Abid, not Maulana Ilyas Ghuman...
Ahmad_shakeel
09-07-2009, 12:11 AM
:salam:It was Maulana Abid, not Maulana Ilyas Ghuman...
yea it was Moulana Abdullah Abid sorry my mistake
There more books of Allama Sarfraz Khan Safdar Has been uploaded here
1. Al Maslak Al Mansoor
2. Sama E Mouta
3. Asahab Al Mubeen
http://www.ahlehaq.com/mamati.html
Ahmad_shakeel
07-08-2009, 03:52 AM
Speech on ilm ghayb
Must listen!
http://www.4shared.com/file/123226381/1fa800c3/Ilm-i-ghayb_-_Allamah_Sarfaraz.html
Ahmad_shakeel
12-08-2009, 11:31 PM
a beralwi said on their forum
Allama Sahib also stood against the Imam e Ahle Sunnat of Deoband Sarfraz Khan Safdar and wrote Tauzih ul Bayan and Maqam e Wilayat o Nabuwat to counter his allegations. And we know Sarfraz Khan was a big scholar and no one could stand up against him but Allama Ghulam Rasool Saidi.
Allamah sarfraz wrote itmam al-burhan fi rad taudih al buyan in 4 vol refuting ghulam rasul saidi and no reply from them now.
this book is amazing
must read - covers tens of topics
Ahmad_shakeel
26-08-2009, 01:56 AM
ahsan al kalam is uploaded in 3 parts
Ahsan al-Kalam Masala Fatiha Khalf al-Imam — a detailed two-volume treatise on reciting Surah al-Fatihah behind the imam in congregation. Shaykh Sarfaraz also dwells on what Imam al-Bukhari and Imam al-Bayhaqi have written on this topic. Shaykh al-Islam Mawlana Husayn Ahmad Madani has, among many other, penned a short preface to this book;
http://www.ahlehaq.com/gm7.html
shatibi
06-09-2009, 11:40 PM
:salam:
How much recognition have `Allamah's book had among the `Arab scholars?
intoodeep
07-09-2009, 12:18 AM
A new website (in Urdu) dedicated to the shaykh:
www.sarfrazsafdar.org
http://www.sarfrazsafdar.org/index.htm
Abu_Uzair
06-11-2009, 04:54 PM
A new website (in Urdu) dedicated to the shaykh:
www.sarfrazsafdar.org
http://www.sarfrazsafdar.org/index.htm
assalamu alaikum
plz see this web for free download of mo.sarfaraz's all books
http://www.4shared.com/dir/2558485/69a1dbdd/sharing.html
safwaan.suleman
17-01-2010, 09:55 PM
Assalaamu 'Alaikum. Are there any books available in Urdu or English with Hazrat's malfuzaat?
hamza_imran
18-01-2010, 07:49 AM
:salam:
Anybody know where from can i purchase Maulana's books in India?
:salam:
Anybody know where from can i purchase Maulana's books in India?
Assalam o alaykum,
Some of Mawlana's books were published by various publishers in Deoband.
You can contact these booksellers:
===============================
Maktabah Naeemiah
Deoband 247554 (UP)
Ph: 01336-223294
===============================
Darul Kitab
Deoband 247554 (UP)
Ph: 01336-222558/222924
A. Mushahid Kadir
27-02-2010, 02:11 AM
What about Khazain as-Sunnah, was that not written by Allamah Safdar Saheb also?
What about Khazain as-Sunnah, was that not written by Allamah Safdar Saheb also?
Assalam o alaykum,
Khaza’in al-Sunan, a two-volume commentary on Sunan al-Tirmidhi, was compiled by his sons from his lectures of Sunan Tirmidhi over the years. Mawlana Sarfaraz has written a beneficial preface to first volume.
abul_hussain
27-02-2010, 06:06 PM
is this book refuting Barelwis available online Chahl MAsaa'il Hazraat-e-Barelviyyah (40 issues concerning the Barelvis) by Allama Safdar Khan.
is this book refuting Barelwis available online Chahl MAsaa'il Hazraat-e-Barelviyyah (40 issues concerning the Barelvis) by Allama Safdar Khan.
Assalam o alaykum,
Chahl Masala Hadrat Barelwiyyah — a collection of 40 ’aqidah and fiqh iissues relating to the Barelwis; originally compiled by Al-Haaj Muhammad Karim Bakhsh and republished by ‘Allamah Sarfaraz with brief annotations.
Can be downloaded here. (http://www.4shared.com/file/231204480/df919049/Chahl_Masail_Barelwiyyah.html)
numanthabit
10-04-2010, 12:33 AM
Assalamu Alaikum
Does anyone know if there is an online copy of Maulana's refutatation of Maulana Maududi, entitled Maududi ka ghalat fatwa?
Assalam o alaykum,
Mawdudi Sahib Ka Aik Ghalat Fatwa (http://www.4shared.com/document/B39O3lu8/Mawdudi_Sahib_Ka_Aik_Ghalat_Fa.html)
numanthabit
10-04-2010, 02:42 AM
Assalam o alaykum,
Mawdudi Sahib Ka Aik Ghalat Fatwa (http://www.4shared.com/document/B39O3lu8/Mawdudi_Sahib_Ka_Aik_Ghalat_Fa.html)
Jazakullah
mininova
09-07-2010, 09:44 PM
Can somebody provide the link for english translation of the book Noor wa Bashar, as it has been mentioned earlier in the thread that it is already been translated to english.
Can somebody provide the link for english translation of the book Noor wa Bashar, as it has been mentioned earlier in the thread that it is already been translated to english.
Assalam o 'alaykum,
Not complete yet.
Assalam o 'alaykum,
Mufti Zar Wali Khan on Izalat al-Rayb ‘an ‘Aqidah ‘Ilm al-Ghayb.
Listen: http://www.4shared.com/audio/y563-zwA/Allamah_Sarfaraz_Khan_-_Mufti_.html
mariadin
27-08-2010, 01:35 AM
Assalam o alaykum,
Taskin al-Sudur fi Tahqiq Ahwal al-Mawtah fi Barzakh wa ‘l-Qubur — a detailed discussion on the lives of the prophets in their graves, death, the soul, punishment in the grave, the hearing of the dead, tawassul, istimdad, etc. This book was written at the request of ‘Allamah Yusuf Binnori and Mawlana Mufti Mahmud. It also consists of introductions by almost all senior Deobandi scholars who were alive at the time of its publication. According to Mufti Zar Wali Khan, this book is the most thorough ever written on the topic, and more detailed than what ‘Allamah al-Suyuti and Imam al-Qurtubi have written;
Can be downloaded at the links below:
http://www.ahlehaq.com/aqaid3.html
http://www.ahlehaq.com/books/book-taskeen-us-sudoor-369-p0.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362403/c6a6263d/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_1.html
http://www.4shared.com/file/114362409/2673cf23/Taskin_al-_Sudur_-_2.html
Assalamualaikum,
Is the english translation available?
JZK. Wassalam.
Ahmad_shakeel
28-08-2010, 06:12 PM
please use the new link of ahlehaq as there were changes made in the website
http://ahlehaq.com/ah/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&Itemid=81&task=viewcategory&catid=21
Antivirus
14-10-2010, 08:30 AM
please use the new link of ahlehaq as there were changes made in the website
http://ahlehaq.com/ah/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&Itemid=81&task=viewcategory&catid=21
:salam:
Brother Ahmad_Shakeel, do you have an english version of your website and does it host english books as well? Please guide me to the appropriate link if it is so.
:jazak:
:ws:
Ahmad_shakeel
16-10-2010, 03:50 PM
:salam:
Brother Ahmad_Shakeel, do you have an english version of your website and does it host english books as well? Please guide me to the appropriate link if it is so.
:jazak:
:ws:
ws
we dont have an english version of our site, but we do have some english books in our site that can be found in books section of our site
Antivirus
17-10-2010, 06:30 AM
ws
we dont have an english version of our site, but we do have some english books in our site that can be found in books section of our site
:salam:
Can you please list the books available in english and the web link for them. Unfortunately I do not understand arabic at all and its very difficult for me to browse the website.
:jazak:
:ws:
Antivirus
17-10-2010, 06:33 AM
:salam:
Can you please list the books available in english and the web link for them. Unfortunately I do not understand arabic at all and its very difficult for me to browse the website.
:jazak:
:ws:
:salam:
Ok I managed to get through the english books. Its available at:
http://ahlehaq.com/ah/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&Itemid=81&task=viewcategory&catid=76
http://ahlehaq.com/ah/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&Itemid=81&task=viewcategory&catid=77
:jazak:
:ws:
mininova
27-11-2010, 07:13 PM
Is Izalat al-Rayb ‘an ‘Aqidah ‘Ilm al-Ghayb By Shaykh (r.a) available online in any laguage??????????????????????????:rolleyes:
Ahmad_shakeel
27-11-2010, 10:00 PM
i did scan some of the pages. but the book is kinda thick and my scanner is not of a good quality so it blurs the end part of the page thats why i stopped waiting to get a good quality scanner .
mininova
27-11-2010, 10:03 PM
I pray that you get the scanner asap and scan this very important book. :)
IBL Network
15-12-2010, 10:18 AM
Izalat al-Rayb ‘an ‘Aqidah ‘Ilm al-Ghayb IS NOT AVALABLE YET BUT ANOTHER BOOK ON THE SAME TOPIC WHICH IS ACTUALLY THE ANSWER TO THOSE MISUNDERSTANDINGS THAT WERE MENTIONED BY BARELWIS IN Izalat al-Rayb ‘an ‘Aqidah ‘Ilm al-Ghayb HAS BECOME AVAILABLE NAMED
Izhaarul Aib fi Kitab Isbaat Ilmul Ghaib
READ: http://www.archive.org/stream/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIsbaatIlmulGaib/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIzbaatIlmulGaib#page/n0/mode/1up
DOWNLOAD: http://www.archive.org/download/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIsbaatIlmulGaib/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIzbaatIlmulGaib.pdf
http://ia700306.us.archive.org/BookReader/BookReaderImages.php?zip=/6/items/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIsbaatIlmulGaib/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIzbaatIlmulGaib_jp2.zip&file=IzhaarulAibFiKutubIzbaatIlmulGaib_jp2/IzhaarulAibFiKutubIzbaatIlmulGaib_0000.jp2&scale=8.902086677367576&rotate=0
maneatinglizard
02-03-2011, 10:45 PM
:salam:
Brother Saad, are you still looking for people to fund the translations?
sherazi
18-03-2011, 01:01 PM
jazakaal
:salam:
Brother Saad, are you still looking for people to fund the translations?
Assalam o 'alaykum,
Not at the moment, but I will contact if anything comes up.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.0 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.