Abu Usama
14-07-2004, 01:18 AM
Salam,
i'm a bit confused after listening to one of Mufti AbdurRahman's dars's online on kitab as-salat (lesson 5).
Okay, the last sitting is a fardh and without it there is no salah. However, if the imam gets up in the 4th rakaat by mistake, and then in his 5th rakaat does the sitting and then the sajdah sahwa, then is the salah valid or not?
Basically, i know that the last sitting is a fardh, but i would like to know if it is a fardh in the say the 4th rakaat of Zuhr and if you miss it and do it in your 5th (with sajdah sahwa), then is the salah valid or not?
Because i always thought this was valid, but now from listening to Mufti Abdurrahman i'm getting the impression that its not. (I say impression because it is not clear)
Wasalam
i'm a bit confused after listening to one of Mufti AbdurRahman's dars's online on kitab as-salat (lesson 5).
Okay, the last sitting is a fardh and without it there is no salah. However, if the imam gets up in the 4th rakaat by mistake, and then in his 5th rakaat does the sitting and then the sajdah sahwa, then is the salah valid or not?
Basically, i know that the last sitting is a fardh, but i would like to know if it is a fardh in the say the 4th rakaat of Zuhr and if you miss it and do it in your 5th (with sajdah sahwa), then is the salah valid or not?
Because i always thought this was valid, but now from listening to Mufti Abdurrahman i'm getting the impression that its not. (I say impression because it is not clear)
Wasalam