Shaykh Mahmud Mamduh's reply to al-Albani on his weakening a narration on Tawassul

[Abul Hasan]

:salam:

With regard to the post here:

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3511&page=1&pp=10

Please find enclosed the introductory pdf file I promised to post here from a work by Shaykh Mahmud Mamduh.

Please see the next post below to read Shaykh Mamduh's 17 page response (arabic). I have had to post this separately because the forum doesn't allow me to post it as one large file, even as a zip file it was "too large"

Wassalam

Abul Hasan

[Abul Hasan]

part 2:

The file was still too large to post here as just a pdf file, it will only allow such a large file to be uploaded as a winzip file - hence you will need a copy of winzip to open the actual pdf file. :cry:

wassalam

Abul Hasan

[samrqandi]

assalaamu alaikum

Jazak allah brother, alhamdulillah what you have posted is really good masha allah. I have given these files to some salafiyyah people and their ignorance really speaks for itself, the reply was well what do our scholars say about it paying no attention to what the huffaz have said about it!

What they totally fail to understand is that al-albani was no huffaz of hadeeth, so his opnion has no weight behind it!

brother if you have anymore information on this issue, do post it up especially shaykh mamduh's replies jazak allah khair

[salman]

Alhamdulilah - read every word. Excellent work

[faqir]

:salam:

JazakAllah khair.

Just thought I'd add the following important reference [kindly contributed to this forum by the brother elsewhere] to this thread as well......

Shaykh Al-Ghumari's refutation of al-Albani [may Allah have mercy upon them both]