night
04-02-2012, 06:23 PM
As-salamu alaykum.
a weird thought has popped up in my head - so i was thinking that the shahadah, the first part of it : la ilaha illa Allah is the testimony that there is no god other than Allah: that it is a negation of the existence of gods other than Allah, but not the affirmation of the existence of Allah. then i got round thinking, what is the evidence of the existence of Allah from the Qur'an or Hadith, is there a verse from the Qur'an that says: "Allah exists" period. then i thought, there are such verses as "all praises be to Allah, the Lord of All Worlds, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful" and how the Qur'an describes that God sent down the Qur'an, and it is he who created man, and created the heavens and the earth, and sent down rain, etc, so Allah must exist because for Allah to possess attributes and carry out actions, He must exist.
But then a weirder thought came, what if the word 'Allah" in the places in the Qur'an can mean "nothing", that is, when it is said, "He sends down the rain" could it mean "nothing sends down the rain", when it is said "We have sent down to you a book" could it mean "nothing have sent down the book" or "Allah who created the heavens and the earth" could it mean "nothing created the heavens and the earth", or "God is one" could it mean "nothing is One"
So i guess my questions are
1. is there any evidence from the Qur'an or hadith that says 'Allah exists"
2. could it be that "Allah" or "We" or "He" mean "nothing", i mean, could it be read such as that, or interpreted such as that, is there a possibility
3. is the verse la ilaha illa Allah mere a negation of other gods other than Allah, is there an affirmation of the existence of Allah in the kalima
and i know this stuff makes me sound as if im sort of a zindiq or a nutjob but trust me this thing this thought running thru your head it gets pretty distressful, it's really troublesome
and thank you in advance for answering
a weird thought has popped up in my head - so i was thinking that the shahadah, the first part of it : la ilaha illa Allah is the testimony that there is no god other than Allah: that it is a negation of the existence of gods other than Allah, but not the affirmation of the existence of Allah. then i got round thinking, what is the evidence of the existence of Allah from the Qur'an or Hadith, is there a verse from the Qur'an that says: "Allah exists" period. then i thought, there are such verses as "all praises be to Allah, the Lord of All Worlds, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful" and how the Qur'an describes that God sent down the Qur'an, and it is he who created man, and created the heavens and the earth, and sent down rain, etc, so Allah must exist because for Allah to possess attributes and carry out actions, He must exist.
But then a weirder thought came, what if the word 'Allah" in the places in the Qur'an can mean "nothing", that is, when it is said, "He sends down the rain" could it mean "nothing sends down the rain", when it is said "We have sent down to you a book" could it mean "nothing have sent down the book" or "Allah who created the heavens and the earth" could it mean "nothing created the heavens and the earth", or "God is one" could it mean "nothing is One"
So i guess my questions are
1. is there any evidence from the Qur'an or hadith that says 'Allah exists"
2. could it be that "Allah" or "We" or "He" mean "nothing", i mean, could it be read such as that, or interpreted such as that, is there a possibility
3. is the verse la ilaha illa Allah mere a negation of other gods other than Allah, is there an affirmation of the existence of Allah in the kalima
and i know this stuff makes me sound as if im sort of a zindiq or a nutjob but trust me this thing this thought running thru your head it gets pretty distressful, it's really troublesome
and thank you in advance for answering