Munazrah of Maulana Ameen Safdar Okarvi (RA)

[Aamir]

Was it in 200 when ther wa ssuppsoe to be a debatre between maulana nomani and a breliw scholar by the name of maulana saqib or something

[navman35]

Was it in 200 when ther wa ssuppsoe to be a debatre between maulana nomani and a breliw scholar by the name of maulana saqib or something

it wasn't a manzarah,allamah saaqib shami can't debate to save his life lol.he tried to cause fitnah in the azmat e sahabah (ra) conference.
i was their when it happened,all what happened was that in the conference of azmat e sahaba (ra) allamah saaqib shaami tried to enterupt the gathering when allamah younas nomani was about to start the bayan so the organizers tryed to explain to him but he didn't listen so allamah younas nomani sorted him out and told him to bring saeed assad and allahmah saqib shaami got scared so allamah younas nomani then started his bayan,i also have that on cassette.it was well interesting to see saaqib shami get a bashing from allamah younas nomani .i thing saaqib shaami under estimated him.it taught him a lesson

[Aamir]

Bro.. ive ben looking for Allama Nomani and Maulana saeed asad talk.. not debate but just a talk sitting next to each other on video.. u know wher ei can get it from

[navman35]

Bro.. ive ben looking for Allama Nomani and Maulana saeed asad talk.. not debate but just a talk sitting next to each other on video.. u know wher ei can get it from

i've seen the diallage on vcr and on audio.it was a very good success for allamah younas nomani.i think it can be available from leeds islamic cassette centre.its really good to watch cuz saeed asad is a very good munazir.their is another munazrah on dua baad salatul janazah with saeed asad. it was a big down fall for saeed asad.

[Aamir]

Allama Saeed Asad is quite a big munazir too... i need to get hold of the VCR's from somewhere.. bro u gt an e-mail add?

[navman35]

Allama Saeed Asad is quite a big munazir too... i need to get hold of the VCR's from somewhere.. bro u gt an e-mail add?

uh yea definitely moulana saeed assad is a top munazir.from amongst the barelvi's i think he is the best cuz he manly stays on the subject.plus he has done a good job on some of the deobandi's and ahle hadith
if u want my email i can send it trough the private message

[bokhari]

AsSalamu 'Alaikum brothers,

You can also find audio lectures and digitized books at http://www.ahnaf.org

You can also find the first volume of his famous book "Majmua-e-Rasaail" at http://www.ahnaf.org/e/downloads-cat22.html

There are three volumes of the above mentioned book (in printed format). Anybody who is interested can buy and read the Dalaail by Maulana Ameen Safdar (Rahimahullah).

He was ghair muqallid initially, but changed to Hanafi after having a conversation with two students of Syed Anwar Shah Kashmeeri (Rahimahullah) (ref: heard in his one of beyaan)

If my information is wrong, please correct me.

WasSalaam,
A muslim brother.

[navman35]

im after another munazrah of master ameen okarvi with kazi abdul rasheed (ghair muqalid) on rafal yadain.its on vcr.

[Al-Burhan]

Assalam O Alaikum

Brother can u plz help me get the munazira by moulana chaan muhammed with those ahle hadith 'scholars'? I mean if it's on the net I would be pleased to get the link or if it's on cd or cassete, can u send it to me on email or something like that? I am in Beijing China so it's not possible to find it here...

MOD: no public posting of email addresses.

waiting for ur repy, if possible send me a private email plz, jazakAllah

[Al-Burhan]

i think the best munazir we have is moulana chaan muhammed cuz he has debated all the top munazirs such as shaikh ul hadith zubair ali zai (known to be a teacher of asma ur rijaal) expert in chains of narrators,also talibur rehman (known to be a specialist on deobandi's and written the book "ad deobandia") and kazi abdur rasheed (the top ahle hadith munazir at the present moment).

Assalam O Alaikum

Brother can u plz help me get the munazira by moulana chaan muhammed with those ahle hadith 'scholars'? I mean if it's on the net I would be pleased to get the link or if it's on cd or cassete, can u send it to me on email or something like that? I am in Beijing China so it's not possible to find it here...

MOD: email clipped

waiting for ur repy, if possible send me a private email plz, jazakAllah