All of Sarf

[godilali]

Is there a comprehensive book in English that covers all or the vast majority of sarf, including baabs, derived nouns, and sab'atu aqasaam?

[muhammadnur]

Is there a comprehensive book in English that covers all or the vast majority of sarf, including baabs, derived nouns, and sab'atu aqasaam?

a book that deals with sarf only?

[godilali]

wa alaikum as salam

Not necessarily just sarf. I am looking for anything that comprehensively covers the science of sarf. If it has additional material, I would not mind.

[muhammadnur]

wa alaikum as salam

Not necessarily just sarf. I am looking for anything that comprehensively covers the science of sarf. If it has additional material, I would not mind.

A New Arabic Grammar covers the material
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/085...lance&n=283155

as well as the Medina Arabic Course. The concepts are spread out through books 2 and 3.

Muhammad-Nur

[maaz]

Shaykh husain's fundementals in arabic are all sarf. vol 1 is out, vol 2, is i think a draft right now.

http://www.sacredlearning.org/shopping/index.htm

[Sunni_Student786]

Anyone know of an answer to the brother's question?

How extensive is "Treasures of Arabic Morphology"? All of Sarf covered by it?

[abuhajira]

you can download and see its extent.. from http://www.al-inaam.com

[Sunni_Student786]

Jazakallah Abu Hajira, however brother, given that I don't have a grasp on the whole of this science, I doubt that I'd be qualified to judge how much of it is covered by the book.

Would anyone here who has studied the whole of Sarf and who has gone through the book "From the Treasures of Arabic Morphology" be willing to comment?

[_Suhail_]

Jazakallah Abu Hajira, however brother, given that I don't have a grasp on the whole of this science, I doubt that I'd be qualified to judge how much of it is covered by the book.

Would anyone here who has studied the whole of Sarf and who has gone through the book "From the Treasures of Arabic Morphology" be willing to comment?

Its sufficient, Just the Khaasiyaat Abwaab, a bit brief, but nevertheless sufficient.

Was-salaam

Suhail Amin

[Sunni_Student786]

Its sufficient, Just the Khaasiyaat Abwaab, a bit brief, but nevertheless sufficient.

Was-salaam

Suhail Amin

What do you mean by "sufficient" in this context?