Hanafi books of Evidenses

[ozgurislam]

As salamu aleykum,

Few books of the Hanafi Madhab which state the proofs are:

A’la Al-Sunan – Zafar Ahmad Al-Uthmani Al-Thanwi

Aathar Al-Sunan –Muhammad bin Ali Al-Neemway. Only Kitab Al-Thahara and Kitab Al-Salah. Very good discussion on the strenght of Ahadith.

Al-Hidaya Sharah Bidaya Al-Mubtadi – Burhan Al-Deen Abu Al-Hasan Ali bin Abu Bakr Al-Marghinani. Compares the Madhahib and their proofs briefly.

Nasb Al-Ra’ya – Jamal Al-Deen Abu Muhammad Abdullah bin Yusuf Al-Zaila’ee. Makes Takhreej of the Ahadith of Al-Hidaya

Al-Binayah Sharah Al-Hidayah – Badr Al-Deen Abu Muhammad Mahmood bin Ahmed Al-‘Aani. Commentary of Al-Hidaya. Explains and discusses many proofs that come in Al-Hidaya

Al-Fiqh Al-Hanafi wa Adilatuhu – Asad Muhammad Saeed Al-Sagarjee

Uqood Al-Jawahir Al-Muneefah fi Adilati Madhhab Al-Imam Abu Hanifah – Muhammad Murtadha Al-Zubaidi. Ahadith narrated by Imam Abu Hanifa which the Aimmah Sittah (the six authentic books of Hadith) have also narrated.

Al-Iktiyar Li Ta’leel Al-Muktar – Abdullah bin Mahmood bin Maudood Al-Musallali Al-Hanafi

[ozgurislam]

its will be better if you state where u took that from (askimam) and quote the whole fatawa.

No need, this was may query to askimam, to satisfy you :

http://www.askimam.org/fatwa/fatwa.p...40ffa16724a9f4

[saud_o1]

Akhi ozgurislam,

He meant that you should post the whole fatwa with the source, and not cut and paste just the answer. I Agree with that.
And not ommitting the name of the shaykh who answered helps too.

[ozgurislam]

Category
Jurisprudence and Rulings (Fiqh)
Title
Im looking for a Hanafi fiqh book with evidenses, i noticed that the written fiqh books on the Hanafi madab are mainly books without evidenses but rather with verdicts like; Nurul Izah, Al Ikhtiyaar, Al-Hadiyya al-alaiyya, Ibn Abidin etc.

Question
Im looking for a Hanafi fiqh book with evidenses, i noticed that the written fiqh books on the Hanafi madab are mainly books without evidenses but rather with verdicts like; Nurul Izah, Al Ikhtiyaar, Al-Hadiyya al-alaiyya, Ibn Abidin etc.

Im looking to something like what the Shafiis have like the Gayat ul Ihtisar of Qadi Shudja which is a fiqh book wit on every point an sourced evidense from hadith and/or quran.

Answer
In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful

Assalaamu `alaykum waRahmatullahi Wabarakatoh

Few books of the Hanafi Madhab which state the proofs are:

A’la Al-Sunan – Zafar Ahmad Al-Uthmani Al-Thanwi
Aathar Al-Sunan –Muhammad bin Ali Al-Neemway. Only Kitab Al-Thahara and Kitab Al-Salah. Very good discussion on the strenght of Ahadith.
Al-Hidaya Sharah Bidaya Al-Mubtadi – Burhan Al-Deen Abu Al-Hasan Ali bin Abu Bakr Al-Marghinani. Compares the Madhahib and their proofs briefly.
Nasb Al-Ra’ya – Jamal Al-Deen Abu Muhammad Abdullah bin Yusuf Al-Zaila’ee. Makes Takhreej of the Ahadith of Al-Hidaya
Al-Binayah Sharah Al-Hidayah – Badr Al-Deen Abu Muhammad Mahmood bin Ahmed Al-‘Aani. Commentary of Al-Hidaya. Explains and discusses many proofs that come in Al-Hidaya
Al-Fiqh Al-Hanafi wa Adilatuhu – Asad Muhammad Saeed Al-Sagarjee
Uqood Al-Jawahir Al-Muneefah fi Adilati Madhhab Al-Imam Abu Hanifah – Muhammad Murtadha Al-Zubaidi. Ahadith narrated by Imam Abu Hanifa which the Aimmah Sittah (the six authentic books of Hadith) have also narrated.
Al-Iktiyar Li Ta’leel Al-Muktar – Abdullah bin Mahmood bin Maudood Al-Musallali Al-Hanafi
And Allah knows best

Wassalam

Ml. Ehzaz Ajmeri,
Student Darul Iftaa

Checked and Approved by:

Mufti Ebrahim Desai
Darul Iftaa, Madrassah In'aamiyyah