Allamah Azam Tariq Shaheed

[hugga12]

are Allama Azam Tariq Shaheed and maulana tariq jameel the same person?

[abulayl]

Sheikh azzam tariq was the classmate of sheikh tariq jamil as long as i know.

[hugga12]

are they deobandi scholars?

[muslim786]

are they deobandi scholars?

Yes, in the general sense. But you cannot say they are fully representative of the deobandis, especially in the case of Maulana Azam Tariq Shaheed (ra).

[hugga12]

why not ? n the case of maulana azam tariq

[muslim786]

why not ? n the case of maulana azam tariq

Most of the senior deobandi ulama did not agree with his methodology and they way his group operated.

[hugga12]

are u talking his resistance group- sipha ?

[muslim786]

Most of the senior deobandi ulama did not agree with his methodology and they way his group operated.

Brother Khanbaba or Maulana Abuhajira should be able to give more details.

[muslim786]

are u talking his resistance group- sipha ?

Basically.

[Ansari]

Yes, in the general sense. But you cannot say they are fully representative of the deobandis, especially in the case of Maulana Azam Tariq Shaheed (ra).

Please do furnish that claim with real proof of ulama and what you exactly mean with 'fully representative'. He graduated from a deobandi madrasa, followed the deobandi ulama and followed their minhaj. Plenty of deobandi ulama can be named that supported him.

If you say that some 'differed' with him, then this not proof at all. It is like saying that Mufti Taqi Usmani is not a 'fully representative' of the deobandi's just because he comes on tv and others don't or some deobandi ulama do not agree with his financial stance etc.