This post is for information purposes only regarding the on going clash between the titans of Ahlus Sunna Wal Jama'a versus the dwarves from Ahlul Bid'a.
The individual who calls himself: Abu Turab, literally meaning: The father of dust, alias: Ali Rida "al-Qadri" from Karachi, boasted and bragged on his regular haunt with a heading: "Mahmood Saeed Mamduh refuted !! another blow to Asharis !" And went onto say:
If you look at the second URL above, one can see that he has scanned up a so called response from his "Muhaddith" Amr Abdal Mun'im (he is not Amru - as misread by the Father of Dust!).
So who is Amr Abdal Mun'im?
He is a young man who according to my research was born on 24/2/1967 - making him nearly 38 years of age. When he compiled this work known as Baratul Zimma against the Muhaddith from Egypt: Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh, he was a few years younger.
Who is Shaykh Mahmud?
He is well over 50 years of age and is well known by those working in the field of Hadith. He took knowledge in the traditional manner with Ijaza from the well known Hadith experts like: Shaykh Muhammad Yasin al Fadani al Makki (d. 1990), Shaykh Abdal Fattah Abu Ghudda (d. 1997), Shaykh Abdallah al-Ghumari (d. 1993) and his younger brothers like: Abdal Aziz, Ibrahim and many others.
Shaykh Mahmud was one of the first scholars to expose al-Albani back in the 1980's in written format. I will Insha'allah attatch a scan of his first book against al-Albani, regarding al-Albani's mistakes with regards to Sahih Muslim, published in 1987.
Of his more later works published directly in expose of the late al-Albani (and other "Salafiyya") in the year 2000/1421 AH is the massive, 6 volume work known as: Al-Ta'rif bi-Awham man qassama al-Sunan ila Sahih wa Da'eef.
It is this latter work that the young man known as Amr Abdal Mun'im tried to refute in a short one volume tract named above and advertised by The Father of Dust as being some sort of significant "victory" over the Asha'ira!
This is merely speculation from his likes, for this book by Shaykh Mahmud has nothing to do with Asha'ira or Maturidiyya, but is an expose of al-Albani and other contemporay pseudo-Salafi Hadith "experts" - and their mistakes in Hadith!
To get to the point, Shaykh Mahmud Sa'eed has replied to the claims of Amr Abdal Mun'im and his ilk back in 2001, and he has published his reply separately and also appended it in the second reprint of al-Ta'rif (at the end of the 6th volume). My own blood brother met Shaykh Mahmud in his office in the United Arab Emirates and brought back these books for my own benefit from the Shaykh directly.
I have also received a short document appended below by a "Salafi" by the name of Yahya al-Adl - who has also shown that Amr Abdal Mun'im is inadequate in his research and claims! So let these hasty rejoicers from pseudo-Salafiyya take note of these points!
Please find enclosed scans to prove that Shaykh Mahmud has refuted Amr Abdal Mun'im.
Abul Hasan al-Hanafi