I've a question,sheikh and anyone who have knowledge please do reply as i need an answer for someone who is studying tafseer and cant move on until they have some answers..
They are on the story of Musa (AS)
The bani israeel were promised a land (which land?) but because they did not obey allah's command they were punished and made to wonder in at teeh for 40 years..
 Was musa (AS) with them at the time in teeh?
 if he was with them woundn't that mean he was also being punished? (main Question)
 did they at this time receive blessings eg manna and salwa aswell as being punished? and why would they receive blessings?
 what happend after the 40 years?