Shaykh Gibril Haddad refutes Mufti Taqi Usmani on Mawlid

[ahmad12]

But he has so many mureeds, he can't tend to them all individually. And perhaps he has spoken out against some of the corrupt practices of his mureeds but it just may not be plastered all over the internet?

[Zubair]

But he has so many mureeds, he can't tend to them all individually. And perhaps he has spoken out against some of the corrupt practices of his mureeds but it just may not be plastered all over the internet?

But he has so many mureeds, he can't tend to them all individually. And perhaps he has spoken out against some of the corrupt practices of his mureeds but it just may not be plastered all over the internet?

That's true, but the question is what does he emphasize and how do the general public view him? Does he emphasize the Sunnah above everything else as the true Mashiyikh do? Why is he always seen in disturbing images, such as someone break dancing in front of him or a female kissing his hands (either i heard this or saw this), etc. The answer is clear to anyone who has the least bit of knowledge about the sunnah.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pgg4ttkPH48
Other videos are worse, intermingling of women and men.
Men and women doing dhikr together
Sitting few feets from women

[NeednoName]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pgg4ttkPH48
Other videos are worse, intermingling of women and men.
Men and women doing dhikr together
Sitting few feets from women

Now don't tell me that the B-boy in the video was making those moves in the state of Wajd.

[ahmad12]

That's true, but the question is what does he emphasize and how do the general public view him? Does he emphasize the Sunnah above everything else as the true Mashiyikh do? Why is he always seen in disturbing images, such as someone break dancing in front of him or a female kissing his hands (either i heard this or saw this), etc. The answer is clear to anyone who has the least bit of knowledge about the sunnah.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pgg4ttkPH48
Other videos are worse, intermingling of women and men.
Men and women doing dhikr together
Sitting few feets from women

Was that breakdancing happening in front of Shaykh Nazim though?

Related question, is he a scholar? Do you have to be a scholar of fiqh to be a murshid?

[umar_italy]

Was that breakdancing happening in front of Shaykh Nazim though?

Yes, you can see him right in front of the dancer, clapping his hands at him...

[ahmad12]

Yes, you can see him right in front of the dancer, clapping his hands at him...

Someone needs to speak to him to get these things clarified. You reckon I could contact him in some way? Does he know English?

[sawaaiq]

Gibril Haddad is still defending Hisham Kabbani and considers him from the "awliya" in the comments on this blog

http://www.yursil.com/blog/2010/06/o...bani/#comments

Kabbani is from the awliya of Bush.

[insufficient]

Do you have to be a scholar of fiqh to be a murshid?

Short answer is no.

[Zubair]

Was that breakdancing happening in front of Shaykh Nazim though?

Related question, is he a scholar? Do you have to be a scholar of fiqh to be a murshid?

You don't have to be a scholar of fiqh, but you better no the basics, rarely do you find murshids who are not masters of the outward sciences.

[khanjee]

Seriously. It's like a combination of the worst of each group.

Don't forget his Shaikh is the extremely dodgy Nazim Haqqani.

how can you give this fatwa have you ever met him.

Gibril Haddad is still defending Hisham Kabbani and considers him from the "awliya" in the comments on this blog

http://www.yursil.com/blog/2010/06/o...bani/#comments

Kabbani is from the awliya of Bush.

are you an atheist.............your religion is mentioned "none"

may be you belong to the bush awlia