Bilal (RA) and pronunciation

[Rahmaniyyah]

Does anyone know of Bilal (RA) having difficulty with his pronunciation of Seen and Sheen?

[Husain]

It is a famous fabrication mentioned in virtually every book on Mawdu' ahadith.

[Rahmaniyyah]

It is a famous fabrication mentioned in virtually every book on Mawdu' ahadith.

Mufti Sahib,

for this - I'm very suprised because I was quite sure of it.

So did Bilal (RA) have any difficulty with his tongue when proclaiming Adhan? Did any Sahabah ever complain about his pronunciation? Why is this so famous?

[Husain]

He had no difficulty at all, rather he was very fasih (eloquent) and called the adhan loud and clear, which is why he was selected by Nabi for the task.

[sudoku]

I've heard this about Bilal so many times that I'm shocked it's a fabrication. for clarifying!

[Rahmaniyyah]

I've heard this about Bilal so many times that I'm shocked it's a fabrication. for clarifying!

Yes I know very shocking it is mentioned so often. Not only is it mentioned but details about "seen" and "sheen" and his pronunciation of them are given. I don't understand why anyone would just make it up with so much detail

for the clarification again.

[a_muslim]

Shaykh Anwar al-Awlaki talks about Umm Aiman radhiyallahuanha (also an abbysinian) having a problem with pronouncing sheen or seen once in a battle (i think) and then Rasoolullah (sallallahualaihiwasallam) told her to stay quiet as she wasnt making any sense.
wassalam

[shatibi]

Mufti sahib.

There is a similar famous narration in which the sun refused to come up - by Allah's will - because Sayyidina Bilal was removed from the position of mu'adhin. Is that also a fabrication?

[not known]

I've heard this about Bilal so many times that I'm shocked it's a fabrication. for clarifying!

I heard from Makki Hijazi saying this as a fabrication

Mufti sahib.

There is a similar famous narration in which the sun refused to come up - by Allah's will - because Sayyidina Bilal was removed from the position of mu'adhin. Is that also a fabrication?

I think you are misquoting it ?

[abulayl]

I think you are misquoting it ?

I heard similar one as brother mentioned. But there are some versions of also cause of ali(rd) prayer.