Does Allah hate sinners or just their sins?

[tariqa]

which one?

[hazratji]

Allah hate sinners because of their sins

[SY1]

sheikh yunus jaunpuri used to say to us that hate the sin, not the person commiting it.

ghalati seh nafrat karoh, sahib e ghalati seh nahi.

[kunnoori]

As Salaamu Alaikum.

"Zahid ko jis khadar khafagi maikashoon say hain
Etna to aasioon say Khudaa bhi khafaa nahin."


Adam Alai Salaam sinned, Allah Ta'aala Taught him to say .... Rabbanaa zalamna anfusana....

If Allah were to hate the sinner, there would not be one living creature on this earth.

Are you not amazed that Rasool e akram salallahu alaihi wasallam was sent as Rahmatullil aalameen, and we are wondering if Allah hates the sinner?

Rabbana zalamna anfusana wa illamtaghfirlanaa watarhamna lanakuunanna minal khasareen.

BUT, if one takes Allah for granted and consider the smallest sin insignificant, which means arrogance on ones part, then as the saying goes,

'GOD HELP YOU'

Allah Ta'aala expects you to keep asking forgiveness and with Sincerity.

May Allah Forgive us all by His Fazl (GRACE). aameen

[hazratji]

If a man doesnt cover his satar and another man sees him. Allah curses both of them.

Allah hates sinner, because of his sin

[tariqa]

As Salaamu Alaikum.

"Zahid ko jis khadar khafagi maikashoon say hain
Etna to aasioon say Khudaa bhi khafaa nahin."


Adam Alai Salaam sinned, Allah Ta'aala Taught him to say .... Rabbanaa zalamna anfusana....

If Allah were to hate the sinner, there would not be one living creature on this earth.

brother
you misquoted that hadith

the correct translation of that hadith goes


if allah were to punish man for his sins on earth, then no one would remain

it never said that if allah hates a sinner then we will destroy him

please learn to translate the verses correctly

thank you

[kunnoori]

brother
you misquoted that hadith

the correct translation of that hadith goes


if allah were to punish man for his sins on earth, then no one would remain

it never said that if allah hates a sinner then we will destroy him

please learn to translate the verses correctly

thank you

As SalaamU Alaikum Brother Tariqa,

Sorry, my mistake. I had not realised you were one of those who like reading recipe books, but does not know how to cook.

[abulayl]

Abu Huraira reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: When Allah loves a servant, He calls Gabriel and says: Verily, I so and so; you should also love him, and then Gabriel begins to love him. Then he makes an announcement in the heaven saying: Allah loves so and so and you also love him, and then the inhabitants of the Heaven (the Angels) also begin to love him and then there is conferred honour upon him in the earth; and when Allah is angry with any servant He calls Gabriel and says: I am angry with such and such and you also become angry with him, and then Gabriel also becomes angry and then makes an announcement amongst the inhabitants of heaven: Verily Allah is angry with so-and so, so you also become angry with him, and thus they also become angry with him. Then he becomes the object of wrath on the earth also.

Here the opposite of love, "Angry" is taken.

[tariqa]

are you saying he doesnt hate anyone
he is only angry with one?

i heard other hadiths that say
Allah hates a certain deed

and he hates such and such sin..

if he hates the sin, wouldnt he hate the sinner at the time of the action?

[tariqa]

thats it?