Quduri (Arabic) editions

[hope1]

Assalamu aliakum,

Which is a good edition of Quduri to buy in Arabic in terms of print and accuracy? I am mainly interested in the following characteristics:

i) Harakat have to be there
ii) Typed (clean and easy to read)
iii) preferably enough space on the margins to make notes

The versions I can see online are the following:

1) Maktabah al-Bushra (al-rashad)
2) Al Misbah Book Land (Buffalo - Darul Hikmah and Azhar Academy)
3) Qadimi Kutub Khana (Buffalo - darul hikmah)

Anyone know which of the above three has the best print?

If I buy from Buffalo I will most likely go there, so I am mainly interested in feedback for the Maktabah Bushra edition from al-rashad and if there are any other editions which is better.

[KeepTheGazeDown]

I have print of مؤسسة الريان with the التصيحيح والترجيح علي القدوري للعلامة قاسم بن قطلوبغا in the هامش. It also indicates the differences of نسخ. I found it to be excellent.

[Ashraf Dockrat]

I have print of مؤسسة الريان with the التصيحيح والترجيح علي القدوري للعلامة قاسم بن قطلوبغا in the هامش. It also indicates the differences of نسخ. I found it to be excellent.

When was this printed?

[KeepTheGazeDown]

In 2008.

[godilali]

In 2008.

as salamu alaikum shaykh,

Are you aware of any electronic copies of al-Tashih wa al-Tarjih?

[Abu_Uzair]

Assalamu aliakum,

Which is a good edition of Quduri to buy in Arabic in terms of print and accuracy? I am mainly interested in the following characteristics:

i) Harakat have to be there
ii) Typed (clean and easy to read)
iii) preferably enough space on the margins to make notes

The versions I can see online are the following:

1) Maktabah al-Bushra (al-rashad)
2) Al Misbah Book Land (Buffalo - Darul Hikmah and Azhar Academy)
3) Qadimi Kutub Khana (Buffalo - darul hikmah)

Anyone know which of the above three has the best print?

If I buy from Buffalo I will most likely go there, so I am mainly interested in feedback for the Maktabah Bushra edition from al-rashad and if there are any other editions which is better.

here in india,the new version of nurul idha and quduri and shuzuruz zahab are amazing with airab and hashiya in very good printing,also in very low prize

[KeepTheGazeDown]

as salamu alaikum shaykh,

Are you aware of any electronic copies of al-Tashih wa al-Tarjih?

I am unaware of an electronic copy but in the link below you can get some other commentaries of quduri:

http://majles.alukah.net/showthread.php?t=58701

You could request the poster to upload the file for you.

[KeepTheGazeDown]

The one in the link is an ilmiyyah print which was published in 2002. Try and search for the مؤسسة الريان print.

[Zubair]

I have the Qadimi Kutub Khana one with Shaykh Maydani (enough space for writing), the tashkil is there for the matn (not for the sharh), though the printing could be better but it's not bad. I do like Mawlana 'Aziz 'Ali's Hashiya(no space for writing though), though not all of the words have tashkil, but the ones that most likely students make mistakes do have tashkil, but if your not used to reading the handwritten desi style texts then it's not suitable. Both of these are extremely accurate (my opinion), the first one because the editor is Shaykh Muhiyuddin 'AbdulHamid who contributed much to arabic grammer which includes his edition of Sharh Qatr un Nada. The second work is by the Ustadh of lugha and fiqh of Darul Uloom Deoband so can't go wrong there.


I've seen the one with Tashih of 'Allama Qutlubugha, it's a good print, but i don't know if it has tashkil

[hope1]

I have the Qadimi Kutub Khana one with Shaykh Maydani (enough space for writing), the tashkil is there for the matn (not for the sharh), though the printing could be better but it's not bad. I do like Mawlana 'Aziz 'Ali's Hashiya(no space for writing though), though not all of the words have tashkil, but the ones that most likely students make mistakes do have tashkil, but if your not used to reading the handwritten desi style texts then it's not suitable. Both of these are extremely accurate (my opinion), the first one because the editor is Shaykh Muhiyuddin 'AbdulHamid who contributed much to arabic grammer which includes his edition of Sharh Qatr un Nada. The second work is by the Ustadh of lugha and fiqh of Darul Uloom Deoband so can't go wrong there.


I've seen the one with Tashih of 'Allama Qutlubugha, it's a good print, but i don't know if it has tashkil

Assalamu alaikum,

I saw the Lubab (Maydani) version from Kadimi Kutub Khana. However I am speaking of the one without Lubab.

If it is typed like the Nur al-Idah Mufti Husain posted that would be great. Also I would need to be able to buy it here in North America.

JazakAllahu khairan to everyone.