Sheikh Kishk r.A. Talks About Where is Allah :)

**Abu Zakariya Yahya** · 11-01-2011, 09:22 AM

Originally Posted by maneatinglizard

You were the one doing ta'wil, not them.

Dear Man eating lizard, You don't know ARABIC. You don't know even how to apply ta'weel to his statement nor do you know his statement, you can only do tafweedh of it assuming that you can atleast read the letters.

Second, you're still being held accountable for your lies against the hanbali madhab.

[clip] let me explain.

The Jahmi said "I don't believe in a lord who can depart from his makaan", al-fudhail "I believe in a lord who can do what he wants".

NOTICE.

1: The jahmi does not believe Allah is above the throne. So he was only doing that to MIMIC the belief of the salaf.

2:The Salaf stayed quiet concerning Makaan.

3:Silence is acceptance.

4:Ithbaat of makaan and action attributes, by saying I believe.

5:Most of your scholars say the Salaf had a simple belief, so that would also mean that their speech was simply and would not need a deep twisting analsyse to come upon an answer you agree with.

This is not ta'weel, and to say it is shows your ignorance 7 fold.