Sheikh Kishk r.A. Talks About Where is Allah :)

[Abu Zakariya Yahya]

Do you even know Arabic? He is quoting the Jahmi who thinks Allah is in place. It seems the Salafis are the Jahmis of today who believe Allah is in a place.

You fail again.

The one who believes Allah is in a place is a murtad. His marriage is invalid and all his good deeds are in vain. As mentioned by all 4 schools of thought.

I don't know what you are talking about seriously, tell me which part of the sentence I didn't understand or misunderstood.

Al-fudhail said if a JAHMIY says to you "I disbeliever in a lord who decends from his place" Say "I believe in a lord who does what he wants"....

Which means two things, number one al-fudail confirmed Allah is in his place(istawa ala'l arsh) and that he decends as he wishes.


If I am wrong explain to me how I am wrong.

He didn't negate Allahs makaan by saying I believe, nor did he deny Allahs decending by saying I believe. Rather he confirmed BOTH. Because the Jahmi Also believe there is nothing above the Arsh, it had nothing to do with the jahmiy believing Allah is above, because they also negated that. It has to do with the Jahmiy negating nuzool, and playing around with the Salaf by saying "I disbelieve in a lord who can't move from his place", the Jahmi even knew that what the Salaf believed, unfortunetly you don't.

Like what was reported from another Salaf named Sa'eed ibn aamr ad-dhoba'ii, who said in abbreviation that the people of all the revealed religions believe Allah is above the throne, whle the jahmiyah say there is nothing upon it.

So rather than make yourself look retarded, shut your mouth.