Nadwatul Ulema v Deobandi Ulema

[Intrepid]

Just wondering if anyone could give me any information on how the Nadwatul Ulema differ from the Deobandi Ulema from an Islamic stand point?

[employer]

the book is available online on "abulhasanalnadwi.org". Its name is "Basair" - on page 23, he mentions that from the very beginning at Darululoom Nadwa, there has been a mix of practices on different mazahibs and even ahle-hadith groups and students have been studying over there and some have also been teaching over there. So, these 3 sentences are elaborate enough to tell that maslak of Nadwa even in the time of Maulana Ali Mian (rahmatulla alaihi) and even before him as mentioned, but with complete due respect to him and all the scholars of Nadwa, has been broad minded incorporating even ahle-hadith group. So, no wonder when we see ahle-hadith scholars like Mukhtar Nadwi etc. though the ahle-hadith is anti-madhab yet that is the case with Nadwa.

[syed1987]

السلام علي من اتبع الهدي

I am feeling really very sorry to say dt comments or posts like these are not suiting to Nadwatululama(the great Institution) and Nadwi scholars, Nadwa is still on that path in which it was established till the date. It has its own mission and vision i e itthadulmillat and ittehadulummat....its madhhab is still Deobandi hanafi but not so strict that it will close the door for Shaafees, Hambalees and Ahlehadeeths

[employer]

Brother syed, this is what I wanted to point out. But since everything needs a reference and a source- Maulana Ali Mian (rahamtulla alihi) has written himself in Basair about it. I have mentioned the link below. I don't intend to degrade nadwa or Maulana ali Mian (rahamtulla alihi) because what they have done for the ummat is enough till qiyamat inshaAllah for all generations to come. Yet when we see mixed people like muhktar nadwi, and jamat-islami nadwi scholars calling themselves nadwi or followers of Maulana Ali Mian (rahmatulla alihi) - it confuses the young minds about nadwa.

Hazrat Maulana Ali Mian (rahamatulla alihi) was incorporating and uniting and not in a defensive attitude towards anyone. So, as mentioned, this was written just to explain the difference between nadwa and deoband maslak. Both have been explained by Hazrat (rahamatulla alihi) himself in the book 'Basair'.

[syed1987]

The world is so advanced u dont need to be confused. watch them then decide u should follow or not even i found a lots of ulema who got their degrees from Darululoom deoband and Mazahiriluloom saharan pur and now they are leaders of Jamaat e Islami or Ehle hadith. i dont wanna disclose their names. but can we say to see people like them that "it confuses the young mind about Darululoom or Mazahir"

Brother syed, this is what I wanted to point out. But since everything needs a reference and a source- Maulana Ali Mian (rahamtulla alihi) has written himself in Basair about it. I have mentioned the link below. I don't intend to degrade nadwa or Maulana ali Mian (rahamtulla alihi) because what they have done for the ummat is enough till qiyamat inshaAllah for all generations to come. Yet when we see mixed people like muhktar nadwi, and jamat-islami nadwi scholars calling themselves nadwi or followers of Maulana Ali Mian (rahmatulla alihi) - it confuses the young minds about nadwa.

Hazrat Maulana Ali Mian (rahamatulla alihi) was incorporating and uniting and not in a defensive attitude towards anyone. So, as mentioned, this was written just to explain the difference between nadwa and deoband maslak. Both have been explained by Hazrat (rahamatulla alihi) himself in the book 'Basair'.