Question About Salafi Belief

[akabirofdeoband]

Brother ansari

I'm not well versed in this topic at all.
But some of your points seem quite radical

What do our senior ulema say about the modern day salafi ideas
Do they goto the degree that you do?

I'm not talking about each specific idea but the whole mass of beliefs put together

[suleimanibnsalim]

What do you expect when we have people talking about a 'general' kalam of Allah, and then specific words with 'originate' from Allah's essence??? Isn't that the exact thing they accuse us of? Believing in two qur'ans!

[maneatinglizard]

Brother ansari

I'm not well versed in this topic at all.
But some of your points seem quite radical

What do our senior ulema say about the modern day salafi ideas
Do they goto the degree that you do?

I'm not talking about each specific idea but the whole mass of beliefs put together

I think it ranges from the specific focus of the scholar.

The ones who specialize in Fiqh tend to focus on the Salafis who reject Taqleed and attack Hanafi Fiqh (primarily Ahlul Hadith and Western Salafis), while the Aqeeda specialists are much more focused on the Salafi Aqeeda experts (mostly the Saudi Salafis, as well as the Mutaqadimeen movement). There are also the Tasawwuf focused scholars who tend to avoid these issues altogether, and the Hadith experts, although I don't know how they figure into the issue.

This is why you see Deobandi Ulema from the Subcontinent focusing most of their efforts on the Fiqh side of the equation as well as refuting Brelwis, as the Salafis from the Subcontinent are primarily focused on Fiqh issues themselves, while the Western Deobandi Ulema tend to discuss Aqeeda issues as well, due to the efforts to spread Salafi Aqeeda in the West.