Major differences in four madhab's ??

[itajamulrahman]

What are all the major differences between these four madhab's hanafi, shafi, malaki and humbali..!

What makes peoples to follow only one imam ?

Why peoples feel it is difficult to follow all four imam's ?

Reply simple so that i can understand i am not highly qualified in islam.

[ahamed_sharif]

Assalamu alaykum

What are all the major differences between these four madhab's hanafi, shafi, malaki and humbali..!

We the followers of the Imams never tried to compare the madhabs. And it will not help you anyway.

What makes peoples to follow only one imam ?

By following one Imam we don't reject the proofs of other Imams.

Why peoples feel it is difficult to follow all four imam's ?

Let the rejecters of madhabs set an example by compiling a fifth madhab with clear study of the four madhabs. Then Inshaa Allah we discuss about the difficulty.

Reply simple so that i can understand i am not highly qualified in islam.

That is a simple reply. Let us close this discussion now. Ramdhan is above us, let us use our energy towards a fruitful ramadhan.

[simpletruthislam]

100 Examples illustrating the differences between sects

Items
Hanafi Maliki Shafi Hanbali

1. Skin of a dead animal
unlawful lawful unlawful lawful

2. Flesh of beasts fed on dirt
- lawful - unlawful

3. Eel
lawful - - unlawful

4. Man’s wearing red
abominable lawful unlawful abominable

5. Man’s wearing yellow
unlawful lawful unlawful unlawful

6. Playing ud, recorder, drum, etc. abominable lawful lawful unlawful

7. Crow flesh unlawful lawful unlawful unlawful

8. Horse flesh unlawful lawful - -

9. Mussels
unlawful lawful - -

10. Oysters
unlawful lawful - -

11. Lobsters
unlawful lawful - -

12. Swallows lawful lawful unlawful unlawful

13. Eagles
unlawful lawful unlawful unlawful

14. Bats unlawful abominable unlawful unlawful

15. Ablution before circumambulation in pilgrimage
duty (wacip) binding duty binding duty binding duty

16. Rehearsing of Fatiha in the first two rekats during prayer.
duty binding duty binding duty binding duty

17. Tasbih in kneeling and prostrating
sunna - sunna duty

18. Rehearsing suras after the fatiha during the first two rekats
duty permissible sunna sunna

19.Rehearsing basmala before the fatiha
sunna abominable binding duty duty

20. Interval between feet during prayer in the standing position
3 inches 16 inches 8 inches 16 inches

21. Vitr prayer
duty sunna sunna sunna

22. Man who touches a boy becomes canonically unclean
no yes no no

23. Does greeting during prayer make one canonically unclean?
yes no - -

24. Interval allowed from the person during prayer.
40 fathoms 1 fathom 3 fathoms 3 fathoms

25. To utter words other than the prayer during prayer annuls it
yes no no no

26. Using a wrong word during the prayer annuls it
yes no no no

27. Sighing during the prayer annuls it
yes no yes yes

28. Is the urine of beasts whose flesh is edible clean? yes no yes no

29. Is the sperm of edible beasts clean?
yes yes no no

30. Number of binding duties in ablution
4 7 6 7

31. Is there an obligatory order of acts during ablution?
no no yes yes

32. Must acts performed during ablution follow an unbroken succession?
no yes no yes

33. Number of sunnas of ablution
17 8 30 20

34. Is the use of miswak sunna?
yes no yes yes

35. Washing hands, face and arms three times sunna?
yes no yes yes

36. Is the three times anointing the head during ablution a sunna?
no no yes yes

37. Is the rubbing of ears inside & outside a sunna?
yes yes yes no

38. How many times must the ears be rubbed during ablution?
once once three times once

39. The number of acts that annul one’s ablution
12 3 5 8

40. Does touching one’s sexual organ annul the ablution?
no yes yes yes

41. Does laughter during pray (salat) annul the ablution
yes no no no

42. Do eating camel flesh and washing the body of the dead annul the ablution?
no no no yes

43. Does uncertainty annul the ablution?
no no no yes

44. Does bleeding annuls the ablution?
yes no no yes

45. Is expression of intention necessary before ablution?
yes no no no

46. Number of reasons for total ablution (gasala)
7 4 5 6

47. Number of binding duties related to total ablution
11 5 3 -

48. Person not performing the pray because of neglect or idleness
is jailed& killed if killed if killed if
beaten& he doesn’t he doesn’t he doesn’t
killed repent repent in repent in 3 days 3 days

49. If the words are not rehearsed successively will call for prayer (ezan) be valid
yes yes no no

50. Can a person who doesn’t speak Arabic rehearse the words of ezan in his tongue?
no yes no yes

51..Must formal resolve be expressed in ezan?
no yes no yes

52. Is greeting permissible during the ezan?
no no no yes

53. Must one rehearse the Fatiha at every prayer? Is it a binding duty?
yes no no no

54.Is salam a binding duty at the end of every prayer?
no to one to one to both
direction only direction only directions

55. Parts of a man that should be covered?
From navel privy parts & from navel from navel
to the knee buttocks to the knee to the knee

56. Portion of a corpse for ritual cleaning before burial
2/3 ½ a portion a portion

57. Must water enter the mouth and nostrils during ritual washing of the corpse
no yes yes no

58. Should person who died during hajj (pilgrimage) be incensed
with perfume and face covered?
yes yes no no

59. Who will conduct the salat performed in honor of the dead?
sultan- person next of person
head of state that the dead kin that the dead
had indicated had indicated

60. Special proscription for the time of performance of salat in honor of the dead?
5 3 every time 3

61 Can body be buried at a location other than the one where death occurred?
yes yes no no

62. Should intention to fast be expressed by word of mouth
yes yes no yes

63. Should a person renew his intention to fast every day in Ramadan?
yes no yes yes

64. Does bleeding annul fasting?
no no no yes

65. Chattel a person owes that bars zakat giving?
all assets gold&silver no all assets
except for grains prescription

66. Should a man or woman give zakat on their jewelry?
yes no no no

67. Should zakat be given on cash?
yes yes yes no

68. Rate of zakat on metals?
1/5 1/5 1/40 1/40

69. No. of conditions related to zakat to be given on traded assets
4 5 6 2

70. Should zakat be given on any valuable thing unearthed?
yes no no yes

71. Should zakat be given on honey produced?
yes no no yes

72.Should zakat be given on land devoted to pious foundations?
yes yes no no

73.Should zakat be given on land rented or held in tenure to be cultivated ?
no yes yes yes

74. Should zakat be given on olives?
yes yes no yes

75.Should zakat be given on cattle fed on foddle or worked in the field?
no yes no no

76. Age of sheep and goat at which they are liable for zekat?
For sheep 1 For sheep 1 For sheep 1 For sheep 1/2
For goat 1 For goat 1 For goat 2 For goat 2

77. Can a woman go to hajj unaccompanied by her husband?
no yes yes no

78. Can a person unable to go on hajj appoint a proxy?
yes no yes yes

79. Number of requirements for hajj?
2 4 5 4

80. Is it permissible that the stone hurled at Satan does not fall on the jamra during pilgrimage?
yes no no no

81. Is it permissible to give food to a poor who is not a Muslim?
yes no no no

82. Is it unlawful to sit on silk, to lean against it or to use it as tapestry?
no yes yes yes

83. Is it permissible for a boy to wear silk?
no no yes yes

84. Is it permissible to use a cup ornamented with silver while taking
ablution or drink from?
yes no no no

85. Is trimming the beard unlawful?
yes yes no yes

86. Is backgammon unlawful?
no yes yes yes

87. Is chess unlawful?
yes yes no yes

88. Should the debts of a dead be paid?
no yes yes no

89. What portion of things unearthed in one’s own land are due to the state?
1/5 0 0 0

90. Is the usurper cultivator of land the owner of the produce he obtains?
yes yes yes no

91. Time within which a contract can be modified or terminated?
3 days according 3 days according to
to the need contract

92. Beast sexually assaulted
killed not killed not killed should be
flesh nor flesh edible flesh edible killed
edible

93. Number of times the cudgel shall be applied to inflict punishment to a drinker of wine or other inebriating substance?
80 80 40 80

94.Will a person stinking or vomiting wine be punished with a cudgel?
no yes no no

95. Can the estate of a religious apostate killed be given to his inheritor?
yes no no no

96. Should a woman renegade be killed?
no yes yes yes

97. Should letting some die by abandoning, imprisoning and leaving him to starve be considered as premeditated murder?
no yes yes yes

98. Can a woman act as a judge?
yes no no no

99. Is a dog a clean animal?
no no yes yes

100. Should a muezzin be paid for his act?
no yes yes no



SO CHOOSE ONE ACCORDING TO OTHER YOU WILL PROBABLY GO TO HELL

[Quandary]

Hah, a khariji Munkar-e-Hadith...

Are you here to post things from free-minds? if so, just leave a link somewhere and then go away.

[ahamed_sharif]

SO CHOOSE ONE ACCORDING TO OTHER YOU WILL PROBABLY GO TO HELL

Mr "simplytruekufr"
If you are not reciting laa ilaaha illallahu muhammadarrasulullah at this instant, you are sure to be in hell.

[Sulaiman84]

SO CHOOSE ONE ACCORDING TO OTHER YOU WILL PROBABLY GO TO HELL

Has anyone told you that differences in Aqeedah draws the line between Iman and Kufr? Not differences in Fiqh.


...Didn't know you had the authority to determine who "probably" will go to hell..

[junfrared]

What are all the major differences between these four madhab's hanafi, shafi, malaki and humbali..!

What makes peoples to follow only one imam ?

Why peoples feel it is difficult to follow all four imam's ?

Reply simple so that i can understand i am not highly qualified in islam.

Asalam Alikum,

Something relatively relevant to you:

Why is Following the Other Madhhab a Punishable Offence

[simpletruthislam]

so i can follow any fiqh or change it too is that ok

[zahed73]

'simpletruthislam'

SO CHOOSE ONE ACCORDING TO OTHER YOU WILL PROBABLY GO TO HELL

I see the shytan works through you.

Signs of one possessed by shytan
They argue a lot
They always think their opinion is right and are not open to others
They think of other human's as less then themselves
They have a high opinion of there own selves
They always shout at people and call them names and they get angry a lot

I was doing some self analysis brother . This nature exists in all humans to some extent as you said

how shaytan works through me? there is shaytan with everyone is there not?

Mine is not so radical and extremist like yours .

Why do you Disrespect Sunnah like that and have extreme views ?

No one is contradicting Quran by following any of the four great imam's
' school of thought ' Fiqh , Anlalysis .

That is all it is .

[simpletruthislam]

how shaytan works through me? there is shaytan with everyone is there not?
why i must follow a fiqh which i got from birth but i dont like it
if all are right than why can i not select one which i like?

it is like if i am born hindu i should remain hindu whole like? or use my brain read quran and accept the truth? what about the rules of fiqh that goes against quran should i follow them too?