Hanbali or Salafi?

[Shahed-560]

What about others 5 Imams of 5 Hadith books ? Did they follow same propaganda or some how they r in same position about this propaganda? Very funny reason.


Brother ur reason makes me to remember a statement of a Imam who was student of Madina University. He said It doesn't required to read lecture or Big volume of Books to understand position Imam Abu Hanifa in the field of Hadith. Just think from this Angel, Absence of Imam Abu Hanifa as a narrator in major 6 Hadith books is the example of his position in the field of Hadith. Although Tirmidi, Abu Dawud , Nasai and Ibn Majah contains Saheeh, Hasan, weak and fabricated hadiths.

السلام عليكم

Looks like he was a Jahil of Jahils of Madina University!

[Shahed-560]

نعمان بن ثابت أبو حنيفة الكوفي مولى لبني تيم الله بن ثعلبة روى عنه عباد بن العوام وابن المبارك وهشيم ووكيع ومسلم بن خالد وأبو معاوية والمقري كان مرجئا سكتوا عنه وعن رأيه وعن حديثه قال أبو نعيم مات أبو حنيفة سنة خمسين ومائة

imam bukhari says in his Tareekh e Kabeer that abu hanifa was murji' and there was defect (sakoot) in him.

Abu hanifa was weaak in hadith and only a fool will deny that.Why don't you hanafis admit that most of the Muhaditheen never liked Abu hanifa and he has been severely criticized by some of them? The excuses that you people pull out to hide the criticism are really childish and of no use.

السلام عليكم
Such ignorance! At least just a cursory search, the Google Shaikh will provide you ample evidence against your above claim. You know it's not true. Don't you? Don't you consider yourself unfortunate for hiding the truth? You are totally blinded by the anti-Taqleed euphoria.

[Shahed-560]

نعمان بن ثابت أبو حنيفة الكوفي مولى لبني تيم الله بن ثعلبة روى عنه عباد بن العوام وابن المبارك وهشيم ووكيع ومسلم بن خالد وأبو معاوية والمقري كان مرجئا سكتوا عنه وعن رأيه وعن حديثه قال أبو نعيم مات أبو حنيفة سنة خمسين ومائة

imam bukhari says in his Tareekh e Kabeer that abu hanifa was murji' and there was defect (sakoot) in him.

Abu hanifa was weaak in hadith and only a fool will deny that.Why don't you hanafis admit that most of the Muhaditheen never liked Abu hanifa and he has been severely criticized by some of them? The excuses that you people pull out to hide the criticism are really childish and of no use.

السلام عليكم

See and hear what your own Salafi scholar is saying about the great Imam (RA) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FqtG-lwvh6g

[AbdurRahmanX]

Imam Hanifa was a great Imam. That is ijma.

[Aram]

Yes i know Arabic Alhamdulilah. You just believe in fairy tales and start throwing them out like a parrot. Hanfi madhab is a Fitna of A'jam and A'jami people.

seems like your issue isn't with the knowledge of imam Abu hanifah RA...its with his race astaghfirullah

[haseeb ahmad hanbali]

In tabqat ibne saad "Imam abu hanifa ra week in hadith"

[Abu Zakariya Yahya]

In tabqat ibne saad "Imam abu hanifa ra week in hadith"

Why are people so worried about Imam Abu Haneefa being weak in hadeeth? The ummah has agreed upon his greatness, that he was pious, and we hope through all of his goodness he is given paradise without hisaab.

If it's not your field of study (Jarh wa ta'deel, 'ilm ar rijaal, and ahadeeth) keep your mouths shut.

[haseeb ahmad hanbali]

Why are people so worried about Imam Abu Haneefa being weak in hadeeth? The ummah has agreed upon his greatness, that he was pious, and we hope through all of his goodness he is given paradise without hisaab.

If it's not your field of study (Jarh wa ta'deel, 'ilm ar rijaal, and ahadeeth) keep your mouths shut.

Brother! it is not my jarah` see it in tabqaat ibne saad. i think you need to study (Jarh wa ta'deel, 'ilm ar rijaal, and ahadeeth)

[Abu Zakariya Yahya]

Brother! it is not my jarah` see it in tabqaat ibne saad. i think you need to study (Jarh wa ta'deel, 'ilm ar rijaal, and ahadeeth)

It has nothing to do with you at all, it's like you going to read a book on brain surgery and then going to a local hospital and telling the surgeon how to perform the surgery.

My comment was not only to you, it was to anyone who uses the statements of scholars against each other, in issues that have absolutely nothing to do with us.

[fikrimubarock]

assalamualaikum. my friend. im new in here. please tell me..., based on madhab hanbali, "where is ALLAH ?"