Doubts / Clarification ON Tablighi Jamat

[AbdAllah313]

Asslamualykum Wa Rehamtullahi Wa Barkatuhu....

Dear Brother's and Sister's If you have any doubts about work of Tablig Jamat ask your questions inshaallah will try to answer it from Quran and HADIS...

[sabm90]

So you're from what country?

[Ahmed]

Asslamualykum Wa Rehamtullahi Wa Barkatuhu....

Dear Brother's and Sister's If you have any doubts about work of Tablig Jamat ask your questions inshaallah will try to answer it from Quran and HADIS...

alhamdulillah there are already many threads on the validity and importance of the effort of dawah

[elusive]

salam brother

I am actually a tablighi aswell and spent 40 a few times but some friends and family have asked questions that I have no answer for

1) when they say that the person in zikr is like the battery of the gasht and if not done properly the gasht will be not proper
2) person staying for zikr in the masjid during gasht
3) amumi gasht - was this ever done by the prophet pbuh
4) did the prophet pbuh or sahabah ever stay in masjid except itikaaf
5) how can maulana ilyas rah "make up this work" by seeing the prophet pbuh in his dream showing him what to do?
6) why only fazail amaal or one or two other book are read only?

[Ahmed]

salam brother

I am actually a tablighi aswell and spent 40 a few times but some friends and family have asked questions that I have no answer for

1) when they say that the person in zikr is like the battery of the gasht and if not done properly the gasht will be not proper
2) person staying for zikr in the masjid during gasht
3) amumi gasht - was this ever done by the prophet pbuh
4) did the prophet pbuh or sahabah ever stay in masjid except itikaaf
5) how can maulana ilyas rah "make up this work" by seeing the prophet pbuh in his dream showing him what to do?
6) why only fazail amaal or one or two other book are read only?

BROTHER,if you have spent 40 days a few times,and cant answer those questions,who did you spend those times with and why have you not seeked the answers to those questions before

[xs11ax]

salam brother

I am actually a tablighi aswell and spent 40 a few times but some friends and family have asked questions that I have no answer for

1) when they say that the person in zikr is like the battery of the gasht and if not done properly the gasht will be not proper
2) person staying for zikr in the masjid during gasht
3) amumi gasht - was this ever done by the prophet pbuh
4) did the prophet pbuh or sahabah ever stay in masjid except itikaaf
5) how can maulana ilyas rah "make up this work" by seeing the prophet pbuh in his dream showing him what to do?
6) why only fazail amaal or one or two other book are read only?

1) i dont think this is meant to be taken as absolute. by this people are just trying to say that success will come through the help of Allah, and if a person remembers Allah attentively and makes dua for the ghusht then inshallah the effects of the ghusht will be better.

2) what about it?

3) i dont think anyone has attributed this method to the Prophet . it is just a method employed to make sure every muslim in the community is visited without missing anyone out. without having a organised system like this many people would fall through the net.

4) please clarify which dream you are talking about.

5) people can read any reliable book they like when they are not in jamaat according to the level of their own knowledge. but in jamaat you have many different people with many differing levels of understanding. if there was no system of reading a particular book then people would bring in all sorts of books which may not be suitable for everyone at best, and which may even be deviant books at worse.

also fazail amaal was actually written and compiled with the activities of tabligh jamaat in mind so it is the best book to be read in jamaat.

[xs11ax]

i have a question...

why do tablighis call those sathis who die in jamaat shuhada, but then wash their body and wrap them in the death shroud when this is not meant to be done for shuhada?

[AbdAllah313]

So you're from what country?

I am from India

[AbdAllah313]

because he died in path of Allah whoever died in the path of Allah he is shaheed

i have a question...

why do tablighis call those sathis who die in jamaat shuhada, but then wash their body and wrap them in the death shroud when this is not meant to be done for shuhada?

[elusive]

BROTHER,if you have spent 40 days a few times,and cant answer those questions,who did you spend those times with and why have you not seeked the answers to those questions before

I have spent my 40 days in the UK from Dewsbury Markaz - these are questions which I have ignored and never been on my mind or were doubts. But they were just questions that have cropped up time to time which I though since this thread was opened would be a good time to ask.

Lets face it bro - most tablighi brother will not know the answer to these questions