you are clutching at straws.
i asked you can you to show me a hadith where the prophet appointed an ameer, a rehbar and a mutakkalim and then sent them to do tabligh amongst the muslims.
instead you tell me...
what has that got to do with the tarteeb of ummumi gusht which is made up of a MINIMUM of 3 people and different people are assigned as ameer, mutakallim and rehbar and then go door to door to houses of muslims?Nabi ρ was the Ameer and the Mutakallim (speaker – chosen for that occasion).
then you jump to...
did the Prophet and sahaba (rd) appoint an ameer when going out in the local neighborhood to talk to and remind muslims of their obligations as a muslim? i have no problem with having an ameer for ummumi gusht, in fact it is a very good idea, but can you show me where the prophet did this when going out in the local neighborhood?The Hadith of Nabi ρ is very clear on the matter that when travelling, one person should be made the Ameer, especially when there are more than three people. Hadhrat Abu Sa'eed Khudri τ narrates that Rasulullaah ρ said, "When three persons set out on a journey, they should appoint one of them as Ameer."
i didnt say its not. but can you show me where they did this when going out in the local neihborhood?Thus, to have small Jamaats with their respective Ameers is conclusively proven.
i didnt say anything about mashwera so it is not relevant here.Subsequently, the whole system of “Mushwera” (Islaamic method and system of mutual consultation) as done in various stages by the Tabligh Jamaat is also automatically proven and given credibility.
obviously someone had to talk, but did they choose a specific person to talk or were they all free to talk?The concept of “Mutakallim” is also adequately substantiated by the above event in History.
again i dont have a problem with the adaab and manner of gusht. all i am saying is that each individual act does not need to be exactly from the sunnah as long as they dont go against the sunnah.
can you give a hadith where peoples names were written down in a book after a bayan?