Need a good English speaking Mufti for my queries

[mohtashims]

Assalamualikum,

Inorder to refute the claims of some half learned "Ghair Mukallideens" where they present a detailed article on refuting the mazhab of Imam Abu Hanifa r.e.h, I need [email contact] a learned Mufti / Scholar to respond to their claim and justify our (Hanafi) mazhab's stance.

I understand that askimam and Daruliftaa never works for me as they never respond to a details research against the mazhab as it looks more acedemic and streched for laymen. Also posting on them would be allowed only one fine day [The day you are lucky ].

I would appreciated if someone could volunteer or provide contacts for the same.

The current issue raised by them (Ghair Mukallideens) is regards to wudu breaking upon touching private part.

[al_Zayn]

Assalamualikum,

Inorder to refute the claims of some half learned "Ghair Mukallideens" where they present a detailed article on refuting the mazhab of Imam Abu Hanifa r.e.h, I need [email contact] a learned Mufti / Scholar to respond to their claim and justify our (Hanafi) mazhab's stance.

I understand that askimam and Daruliftaa never works for me as they never respond to a details research against the mazhab as it looks more acedemic and streched for laymen. Also posting on them would be allowed only one fine day [The day you are lucky ].

I would appreciated if someone could volunteer or provide contacts for the same.

The current issue raised by them (Ghair Mukallideens) is regards to wudu breaking upon touching private part.

I think the 'Ulama and Muftis are very busy, this refutation thing takes alot of time, you cannot just overwhelm them with alot of mis-interpreted material. If you send in one question at a time that would be great.

Or you can just post here your queries and Insha-Allah if someone has the answer they will reply.

What exactly are they saying regarding the breaking of wudhu by touching the private parts?

[mohtashims]

What exactly are they saying regarding the breaking of wudhu by touching the private parts?

Brother its a huge article 8 pages long refutig the claims of the Ahnaf that the wudu does not break upon touching the private part.

It's like the post-mortem of the hadees around the subject.

Can I somehow email it to you ?

[AimeSi]

This kind of issue is from the furu and not the ussul of the dîn. The scholars have differed on this since the earliest, I'm not sure it's useful to spend time in arguing about such issues where the imams have made ijtihad.

wAllâhu A'lam.

[al_Zayn]

Brother its a huge article 8 pages long refutig the claims of the Ahnaf that the wudu does not break upon touching the private part.

It's like the post-mortem of the hadees around the subject.

Can I somehow email it to you ?

What you can do is post the first narration and their issues with that, and we'l take it from there, Insha-Allah we will do their post mortem, 'Ulama and other learned Brothers are welcome for the autopsy examination and give their valuable insights.

[mohtashims]

What you can do is post the first narration and their issues with that, and we'l take it from there, Insha-Allah we will do their post mortem, 'Ulama and other learned Brothers are welcome for the autopsy examination and give their valuable insights.

Assalamulaikum,

The article I have is formated in word with colors and bullet points which will disturb the formatting if I post the article in here.
Can you email me at ************@gmail.com or respond back with your email address.

I will share the article with you.

[Ansari]

The issue of touching the private parts and not breaking the wudu is very simple to defend. Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn Uthaymin held the same opinion. Moreover, the hadith of Talq ("is it only a part of you?") is declared authentic by Albani but he interpreted it as touching with lust. There are other athar from Sahaba showing they held the same opinion as narrated in the Musannaf of Ibn Abi Shayba.

[al_Zayn]

Assalamulaikum,

The article I have is formated in word with colors and bullet points which will disturb the formatting if I post the article in here.
Can you email me at ------- or respond back with your email address.

I will share the article with you.

Im sorry brother i wouldn't want to take that. Nor do i have time. Just post it here one by one. Even Brother Ansari has an idea of what it maybe entailing, so let it be a collective effort rather than a one man.

[mohtashims]

JazakAllah Brother Zayn,

Yes. Part 2 is what I need a rebuttal for. Some Brother X whom I dont know was having a discussion with this Ghair Mukallid named "Omair Hanifa" who happens to write x-Deobandi in his signature :P

Not sue where he gets his materials from but he keeps posting from a technical angle regarding issues pertaining to the Hanafi Mazhab.

We had a to look out for help when he started posting on IBM Muslim software engineers email group of which I am a part of.

May Allah accept all your help and efforts in this regards.

[al_Zayn]

JazakAllah Brother Zayn,

Yes. Part 2 is what I need a rebuttal for. Some Brother X whom I dont know was having a discussion with this Ghair Mukallid named "Omair Hanifa" who happens to write x-Deobandi in his signature :P

Not sue where he gets his materials from but he keeps posting from a technical angle regarding issues pertaining to the Hanafi Mazhab.

We had a to look out for help when he started posting on IBM Muslim software engineers email group of which I am a part of.

May Allah accept all your help and efforts in this regards.

Wa Iyyak,

Part 2, the download on the blog? Brother that is 96 pages LONG! It's multi-colored and some words are capitalised. I can barely understand it, and again it seems like a refutation / answer session.

Like i originally said, get the specific hadith, which the GM's have objections to and post it here.